Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Walter Mashburn

Walter Mashburn
Suspected in 325 theories

THE THEORIES

Okay just for the sake of proving that no matter how terrible Heller messes up the story line, it can still be fixed even though it's extremely unlikely.  And to prove that no matter how delusional my past theories have seemed, I can still get more delusional just for the fun of it.  Remember how Strawberries and Cream had a part one and two?  The Red John episode is also two parts.  We've seen part one where nothing makes sense.  It all comes down to what happened in that house before it blew up.   Jane has Reed, Bertram, and McAllister against the wall.  McAllister breaks and starts confessing about the tiger tiger organization, that's when the "no!" we hear before the gunshot happens, Bertram yells to get McAllister to stop and Jane fires a warning shot that stops all the commotion.  McAllister tells Jane about the tiger tiger group and makes a deal with Jane to help him in exchange for immunity.  Jane knocks Bertram and Reede Smith out.  He lets Stiles and Haffner go in exchange for their promise to lay low until everything is over.  Haffner is reluctant but Stiles agrees and promises that Haffner will do as he's told.  They drive away in the car that passes Lisbon.  Jane and McAllister go get three bodies that Jane stole from the morgue and put them in the house.  Jane also broke switched the DNA in the computer.  They drag Bertram and Reede into the next room and Jane makes McAllister promise to meet in the church in two days.  McAllister leaves and Jane blows up the house with himself, Reed, and Bertram in the room over just before Lisbon gets there.

From Jane's preparation it is easy to tell that he knows that RJ was never one of the people on the list.  The list was a list of tiger tiger suspects given to Jane by RJ to expose the tiger tiger club as I explained in my previous theory:  http://www.whoisredjohn.com/See-a-theory-Red-John/11369.  Now, how to explain the episode we just watched as Jane's elaborate con to catch RJ.  First,  Lisbon's phone was bugged by RJ in the first episode of this season.  That was the major clue, RJ called Jane on Lisbon's phone.  Second, where is Lisbon's phone?  Jane stole it from her when he hugged her before abandoning her on the side of the road.  Jane doesn't take the phone with him into the house before he blows it up so the first RJ hears about the bomb is from the media and perhaps from local police.  RJ assumes that the tiger tiger club set the bomb to kill the tiger tiger suspects and Jane before the organization was revealed.  

Jane announces to the press that Bertram is RJ and the manhunt begins.  At the end of Fire and Brimstone, Jane goes to the church where he agreed to meat with McAllister.  Jane lays out the plan to catch Bertram and RJ.  McAllister is able to contact Bertram using secret tiger tiger methods without letting Bertram know that he's still alive.  He instructs Bertram to kill off Jane and suggests that Bertram pretend to be RJ to lure Jane in.  McAllister and Jane finish planning and split paths.  Jane goes back to his loft and recovers Lisbon's phone from where ever he put it so we know that RJ is listening again.  All Jane has to do then is wait for Bertram's call.

Moving on the the church scene.  Jane and Bertram have that little talk and then Oscar shoots Bertram.  Now, Oscar knows McAllister so when McAllister steps into the church, Oscar follows McAllister's instructions and waits outside.  Jane still has Lisbon's phone with him so RJ hears the entire pretend conversation between Jane and McAllister.  RJ thinks that McAllister is the head of tiger tiger and is pretending to be RJ.  RJ hears Jane defeat McAllister with a pigeon and then shoot him, shoot Oscar, and start on the chase.  But the gun was a prop, so McAllister wasn't actually hurt which explains why he was able to run a mile.  RJ hears Jane chase McAllister down, the 911 call, Jane's disinterest in explanations, the psychic claim, the sound of strangling and death, and Jane's call to Lisbon that it's over.  Then Jane throws the phone away meaning that RJ no longer has ears on the situation.  

RJ is going to be furious.  It is going to tick him off that Jane thinks he's some bumbling idiot that got defeated by pigeons and was a coward that called 911.  The beginning of the next episode will start from RJ's perspective.  RJ will meet up with Jane and they'll start talking.  Jane will explain everything that I just explained in just a few quick flashbacks that makes everything clear.  RJ will explain tiger tiger's presence in the season 3 finale which will explain why RJ sent Jane a list of tiger tiger suspects.  
Jumping over to Lisbon's perspective.  Based on what Abbot(?) tells her about the church crime scene, Lisbon is going to realize that Jane has a con going on and that he faked McAllister's death.  She'll then go looking for him to save him from the real RJ.  Alternatively, she realizes Jane is about to go into hiding and she'll never see him again so she goes looking for him.  Lisbon gets the team to help her escape from the FBI and she goes to find Jane.  Jane never expected Lisbon to be able to find him and it is a great indicator of how well Lisbon has come to know Jane that she succeeds.  She walks into where ever it is that Jane and RJ are and is surprised to see that Jane is not really making escape plans.  He's just sitting there talking to Walter Mashburn of all people.  "Hi Jane, Hi Walter"  This puts Jane into a very awkward position because he just realizes that he encouraged Lisbon to sleep with RJ and he desperately wants to protect Lisbon from the knowledge that she slept with a serial killer.  Walter's just standing there smirking because he thinks the whole thing is very funny.  Jane is also is the position of admitting to Lisbon that he's been lying to her since the season 5 finale.  Jane tries to get Lisbon to go and his concern has her realizing that Jane thinks Mashburn is RJ.  She's the one that mentions the elephant in the room and starts trying to convince Jane that Mashburn can't be RJ because she slept with him and . . . and . . . and . . .she punches Mashburn square in the face.   Mashburn uses this opportunity to escape and he goes off and kills Rigsby and Van Pelt because we know they're not returning for the rest of the season.  There has to be loss on both sides for RJ's death to seem real.  What would the ending of Harry Potter have been like if none of the good character died to balance out Voldemort's death?  Now either Mashburn escapes and Jane tracks him down two years later in South America where he kills him or Jane kills Mashburn and then flees to South America because he could never prove that RJ was Walter Mashburn.

Actually, after writing this theory out, I can see it happening next week.  If you watch the promo for next week, it looks like the Mentalist is changing into a soap opera so that may just be another red herring.  And when everyone hears about the huge reveal next week, they'll all come back.  Anyway, no matter how it turns out, I've had fun on the website so let's say our goodbyes in the comments below unless of course my last and most delusional theory turns out to be correct and then I suppose I'll see you all next week.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Okay, while I wasn't thrilled with the choice of McAllister, when he revealed himself, they could have made him act more like Red John and less like the Sheriff.

I don't know where this leads next, but I am hopeful that perhaps this was another Strawberries and Cream strategy. They made McAllister deny being Red John (in the episode with the explosion at Jane's house), they made him beg for his life, whine, die because of a pigeon, etc. The guy in Strawberries and Cream would have been better staying Red John than this portrayal.

I'm sad nothing but the bomb was explained. I hope we will learn more, rather than it dying. And I really hope Heller is messing with us, getting us fired up before a REAL twist. Otherwise, it seems like he is trying to get the show off air with the lame, hole filled scripting.

By the promo, looks like they are jumping into the future like they did when Jane went AWOL. I'm curious about what change will occur. It'd be nice to see Lisbon settle down maybe with someone like...Walter. ;) Grace and Wayne need some kiddos (if they aren't off the show yet). Cho, I could see in jail. It looks like the FBI guy will be sticking around. I like that, considering I am a Prison Break fan. :D

What's weird is how little the promo for Episode 9 looked like a crime show. It looked like a soap opera or something. LOL

Welp, I'll keep thinking of predictions and rattling my brains for ways Heller could fix the Red John mishap. There's always hope!

And btw, "He is Ma" makes no sense with McAllister...

- Tina

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

So while we're waiting because seriously who isn't just sitting at their computer constantly refreshing the page, let's share our favorite Mentalist art - post in the comments.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

After reading all of these comments I'm convinced the "leak" is a spoof.

Here's what I think is gonna happen...McA is alive but is not Red John. The dialogue between Jane and McA in "Fire and Brimstone" leads me to believe they are somehow working together.

Remember Jane asking, "will you help me catch a killer?" and the weird look McA gave PJ in the house? I think that the sheriff will die helping Jane catch RJ.

And if the episode is a spoof, the "list" is too. Red John is probably Walter Mashburn and what an ending that would be.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Well, it seems that everyone left on the website believes the episode to be a fake.  It took me some time but after watching it for a second time, I too have joined the fake episode theory.  It was actually very funny the second time I watched it.  

Now on to my point:  The majority of people that think the episode is fake still believe that RJ is going to be one of the seven suspects.  Everyone on that list is no longer eligible to be RJ unless the real episode is going to be just like the parody by having someone magically return from the dead.  Do you really think the writers thought "lets film a parody to mess with the fans where we have a different guy return from the dead"?  No, the only way the writers would ever make a fake episode is if RJ was never on the list.  There's the real episode with the huge twist that RJ was never on the list and that the list was in fact RJ's list given to Jane to expose the tiger tiger club.  RJ's list has always been a red herring for the audience which is why making a parody episode why RJ does actually turn out to be on the list is possible.  If the episode is fake then it is the ultimate clue that RJ is not present on the list.  No one is going to return from the dead in the real episode.  If Bertram appears at all it will just be the FBI and Lisbon arresting him which will clue Lisbon into the fact that Jane lied to her and is presumably off catching the real RJ.  

RJ is going to be Walter Mashburn.  The bomb should clue people in on that.  Mashburn started out making cherry bombs in reform school and his first company made high tech weaponry.  He is the only suspect that has a past with bombs.  We are going to be able to look back and watch episodes RJ has appeared in and see the clues and the only suspect that is going to work with is Mashburn.  Both of his episodes were filled to the brim with clues and motives to show that he is RJ.  I have written too many theories on this to spend any more time writing it out.  

The point is that if the episode is fake, then RJ cannot be on the list of seven suspects regardless of whether you think I'm right about Mashburn.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

So IF we are getting an alternate ending, I have NO PROBLEM supposing that the list of 7 is fake.  Just saying.   

Cue Mashburn....

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on