Who is Red John?

Theories of Geni2001 (5)

I haven't been back here since last Sunday so I have to read some more entries. However, this has been a fun place to theorize and see how other viewers' minds work. One question: if you "don't give a shit who Red John is, why are you here." But the answer is clear: you do. The Mentalist is a really well written show that goes much deeper than other detective dramas. See "the forest for the trees". We have all become "mentalists" because of Patrick Jane and the brilliant writers.

With that said, and without reading more theories before I say this I say "he is Mas..."- Walter Mashburn. He is the only other interesting, charming and multi-layered character like PJ. And he is the only man who we know had a fling with Lisbon. How ironic...

Thank you, show, you have taken me into an interesting world.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

he is ma.... Walter Mashburn

Only other male character with any charisma (except Stiles who is too old)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

http://youtu.be/nS9MTm2V8dk

Just check this out.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

After tonight's episode it's obvious to me that Jane himself has lots of wealth. His house, right on the beach in Malibu Bluffs is all closed up & vacant while he lives at the CBI office. The only guy with the money, charm, smarts good looks and smile like Patrick's is Walter Mashburn. I also thought it was a HUGE clue that WM slept with Lisbon- to me it seemed like a show of control over Patrick's closest friend and confidant, Lisbon. Remember that Patrick was intimately involved with Red John's former lover, Loralee. Lisbon doesn't seem to have a romantic life so seeing her in bed with WM surprised me and no further mentionl was made out of it. Very odd.

I hope it's not some huge conspiracy of cops and FBI as they keep hinting at. Or followers of Bret Stiles. That seems so cliche'd. Personally, I'm tired of everything being seen as conspiracy. Let it be Walter Mashburn. And please tell us soon.

PS- The only other interesting twist would be that PJ is RJ. It would be hard rehabilitating him for future shows, though. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on