Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Unrevealed suspect

Unrevealed suspect
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

Given IP address tracks back to CBS hardly surprising
Only theories that wrong are endorsed
Egg face Sunday
Hard to believe you can even follow the show

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Can someone please tell me what is going on ?? How does everyone know who Red John is when the episode hasn't been aired yet ? Or has it ??? Please Explain :((

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

**** this bullshit. If indeed McAllister is Red John, why would you post that knowing that there are thousands of people who visit this website. Even if it was a stupid ass ending you shouldn't just spoil it like that for everyone. And also, why the hell would Bruno Heller release the episode early to the press, he should know that it will be eventually be leaked. I just hope he released a fake video so we can all be shocked the right way.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

are you all smoking crack?
i mean please, dont be so frickin' stoopid!
after six years of hype and suspense you believe the shows producers firstly leak the finale to some idiot, that the idiot is allowed without fear of prosecution or breach of confidentaility clause to leak the plot and ending of the finale, and that CBS dont remove the link?
hello? planet earth to everyone...are you there?
doesn't anyone smell the faintest whiff of a mentalist twist here or are the beer fumes to over powering??
the obvious release of misinformation to get you all nashing your teeth and wringing your wirsts.
its a set up. sure as day.
in a twist you could almost predict the "spoiler" is simply Heller and CBS having a laugh at you.
can we all put our brains together and come up with at least one cell and think it through.
sheesh.  theres been some good theories. dont give in now!
ok, good nite.
all my love
rt

p.s its not the sheriff. ha ha. i have a friend (lets call her Eliza) and i trust her.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

are you all smoking crack?
i mean please, dont be so frickin' stoopid!
after six years of hype and suspense you believe the shows producers firstly leak the finale to some idiot, that the idiot is allowed without fear of prosecution or breach of confidentaility clause to leak the plot and ending of the finale, and that CBS dont remove the link?
hello? planet earth to everyone...are you there?
doesn't anyone smell the faintest whiff of a mentalist twist here or are the beer fumes to over powering??
the obvious release of misinformation to get you all nashing your teeth and wringing your wirsts.
its a set up. sure as day.
in a twist you could almost predict the "spoiler" is simply Heller and CBS having a laugh at you.
can we all put our brains together and come up with at least one cell and think it through.
sheesh.  theres been some good theories. dont give in now!
ok, good nite.
all my love
rt

p.s its not the sheriff. ha ha. i have a friend (lets call her Eliza) and i trust her.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I'm surprised so many people would believe that this would be the real episode.

They accidentally posted the real episode up on their own website two days before it aired?
Come on people!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Wait for a moment!
The first spoiler was that Partridge is Red John, after a lot of people said that the Sheriff is RJ. Everybody claim, he/she saw the episode. I believe it! It's possible they made alternate endings, so we can't be sure it's the real episode. The rest are the same in the episodes, except the identity of Red John! Jane kills Red John the same way etc. Yesterday I thought that Red John is Partridge, and I woke up in the morning, and i saw its Mcallister. So what the hell are going on? ( I'm from Hungary, so we are in the morning ). I hope the real episode will be different like that, which people spoilerd!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on