Who is Red John?

Theories of M_Neuer (2)

Can someone please tell me what is going on ?? How does everyone know who Red John is when the episode hasn't been aired yet ? Or has it ??? Please Explain :((

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Ok, First of all. Let us assume that all what Bruno Heller said was true. He said that one of the 7 suspects is infact Red John. Let us do an elimination process by connecting the things Heller said.

Brett Partridge - Heller said he is dead so let us cross him out of the list

Bob Kirkland - On 2011, Heller said that Red John is someone we know and Kirkland appeared on 2012 so let us cross him out as well.

Reede Smith - We all know that he cannot be Red John since he is too fat to fit the Red John we saw who kidnapped PJ.

Bret Stiles - Sophie Miller said on the recorder that he is on his mid-thirties and Stiles obviously is not.

*That leaves us with 3 Suspects: Bertram, Haffner and Sheriff Tom McAllister.

Most of you thinks it is Haffner which is possible because of the whistle he did after talking to Lisbon. And he calls her Teresa just like Red John does. And when Sophie Miller said on the recorder that he is a great whistler, they showed Thomas Mcallister so you all assume that it is Haffner since they didnt show him.

But they obviously meant to do that so that we will think it is Haffner. I mean we all know how the Mentalist writers think, and it is usually difficult to predict who is the murderer in each episode.So I dont think they will make it that obvious.

That leaves us with Bertram and McAllister. 
Personally, I think that Bertram is innocent just in my opinion. So I'm going with Thomas McAllister. But its still possible it is Bertram or Haffner since there is no valid point that they cant be Red John.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on