Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

Well, Red John''s return is looking more and more slim.

Just saw an interview with Heller regarding the show being renewed. He reiterated Red John was McAllister and the characted is indeed NOT part of the show.

Heller stated:

"We know some folks think the Red John ending could have been different, but the show was not about him. We wanted to give Jane closure on his family's murder so he can focus on being a mentalist. That is what the show is about"




Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I saw on the news that the show has been renewed.

What can I say?  People hoping for Jisbon will now have to contend with a season ending without a definite answer on the relationship, and endure through a whole season next year to see them get together, break up and then perhaps make up for the show's finale.

Yeah!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

What I hate the most are the constant Red John clues that they still give us... the 3 dots on Pike's table, everything lately seems RED (clothes, rooms, ilumination), etc. 

I stopped when Pike and Lisbon were changing channels and on the TV guide it said "Live at the RED something"... I mean SERIOUSLY? It makes it more painfull

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I'm just bored to death. I just can't believe they chose to don't give a damn about giving more backstory about RJ in the 6x20, it was our only chance to see something else about the character...

This is just so dumb, so stupid, so insulting. 5 fuckin' years building theories, BECAUSE of Bruno Heller and this crew of dumb screenwriters, with such things as :

-RJ has worked with Visualize!
-RJ has turned Krye into a mindless zombie!
-Kirkland kills a RJ accomplice EVEN IF IT IS STUPID AND POINTLESS (there WOULD have been a point IF Kirkland was the long lost twin)...
-etc etc...

And in the end, nothing, nothing, nothing. They just... Blow up... Visualize's leader... a worldwide sect... with absolutely NO consequences... they just put that stupid and lonely sheriff, pigeonphobic, as the great RJ who seduced countless women, turning them into his drones, using some psychopaths and making them believe in him to the point of gladly giving their life in his name...

Oh god, oh god... I just hope, please, that someone will write a book, even a databook, telling us how to explain all this shit...

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I'm tagging on to Hll' theory here with the Casablanca reference.  Have you guy's ever seen the final scene of that movie?  I'm beginning to wonder if Heller did this on purpose to foreshadow the Lisbon/Jane relationship?  If he did there are going to be some REALLY PISSED OFF shippers in a couple weeks!!  Haha!  --------Rick (Jane) doesn't get the girl.  Ilsa (Tunney) leaves on the plane with her lover and both never confess their love.---------Hoooooboy!  Now EVERYBODY will hate Heller and not JUST US!!!  Hahaha!!!!!!!

Sorry for the Jisbon-y  Non- Red John post but it just had to be said.

Watch the original Casablanca final scene here. ----->  http://youtu.be/7SQuyKlt1Ew

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

What do you think of Heller's new upcoming series, Gotham?


Green:   He can go to hell, not interested.
Red:      I will give it a try, who knows.


Mine is green.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

It's been a while since i posted a theory here.. anyone remember the good old times when we were all going crazy trying to find out who was Red John? "The Partridge's Loyals", the haters... damn i miss that haha... so many theories, so many good ideas, hopes.. TM was a good show, an amazing show that every week was able to make us gone crazy about all that mystery..

"My Blue Heaven" was a good episode, ok... but i've just stoped watching the show some episodes ago, i didn't even see the "White as the Driven Snow" episode.. all i can do now is read here how the series is going... IF, just IF the season finale be something awesome, with a major twist and RJ coming up again.. then i'll watch it again.. but i dont think the series will last with the path they are going.. sadly.. such a good show.. 

Heller sucks... 

Cheers!

(:

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on