Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

The Mentalist 6x8 - Red John - Sheriff Thomas McAllister is Red John

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EsnqP1PummY 

2:15 minute

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Patrick Jane  vs Sheriff Thomas McAllister (Red John) - Death scene -

http://youtu.be/KAqBO4Hx16I

13:12 minute

#GoodByeRedJohn

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I AM NOT ACCUSING MCALLISTER.


So, I haven't looked for the "leaked"" episode.  I seem to think it is probably real though.  Why would they film and edit a whole episode, just to leak it and set us on a wild goose chase?  Now, if they did do that, it probably is the most elaborate rouse in television history.  Just want to see what you all think...

Click "plausible" if you believe the "leaked" episode is the real deal.

Click "unlikely" if you believe the leaked episode is fake.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Please leave a plausible or unplausible, I would definitely like to see if my opinion is shared, or leave a comment. 

IF you haven't seen the link, do not read any further, for supreme spoilers lay ahead... If you want to see it, find the link here.: 
https://mega.co.nz/#!TRMRySoa!...password for unzipping: mohannad (however, I might recommend just waiting for sunday night. it's two days. Not a big deal.)

We have who it is. There's absolutely no way it could not be McAllister, as it takes days, sometimes even weeks, and tons of money to hire him for the time. They wouldn't do that. Some smaller details during the scenes with McAllister might change, but it is definitely him. Please, please, please stop saying it's Partridge. He's gone with the pigeons.

I personally didn't love the episode. It could have been a lot better. But it also could've been a lot worse. They could've just ended with Jane shooting him. They could've ended without any explanation whatsoever. However, it didn't cover two things I really wanted to know - how the hell did he get the list, and what did all those women see in him?

I believe those will be explored more in "Green Thumb" and "My Blue Heaven". In the meantime, Californians can sleep tight. Unless the Blake Association is coming - then you're screwed.

Tyger Tyger.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Jimmy Gadd: "I know you're angry that fans are spoiling this Sunday's episode. The CBS Press site was hacked & a link was shared of the unfinished show."

Jimmy Gadd: "Just ignore the spoilers & watch the complete & finished episode this Sunday. I'm sorry it happened but thank you for being such great fans!"

Twitter: @jimmygadd

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Idk, the whole leaked thing was 45 mins, so all the scenes were there. Sound and music can only do so much.The main complaint is that there are many questions unanswered. Thats fine with me. It makes sense in PATRICK'S perspective. Patrick doesn't want to give this disgusting piece of inhuman filth the satisfaction that he was curious. Red John thrives on attention and appreciation. Patrick's last words to him and his refusal to hear any explanations from Red John was him spiting him. Serial killers like red john kill for a reason. They like to feel "special" when all they are is abominations. Red John created this mystique and mystery crap around him, and Patrick refusing to give a crap about his trick and how he did them is him completely killing Red John, in both soul and body.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The Mentalist 6x8 - Red John - Sheriff Thomas McAllister is Red John

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EsnqP1PummY 

2:15 minute

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Patrick Jane  vs Sheriff Thomas McAllister (Red John) - Death scene -

http://youtu.be/KAqBO4Hx16I

13:12 minute

#GoodByeRedJohn

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Just saw the episode. It wasn't that bad, but of course it could have been much better. Don't forget that many of us were "spoiled" before seeing, so the twist had less impact. I liked the subtle way they found to explain the voice of Red John, that was nice, which makes me think that maybe heller did know who Red John was meant to be.
The pigeon scene was a bit of a stretch, and made Red John look less menacing, and a weaker villain. Overall it was nice, and they can answer some questions in next episodes, i would like to know how he knew about the list.
Jane got what he wanted, not in the epic way i expected from this show, but overall makes sense.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on