Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

thanks for nothing, after 6 years of watching this show, this fucktard is red john.
like he is a good actor and everything but wtf!

a list fucking bruno heller must fix:

1. Explain how the fuck he was red john show us flashbacks jesus christ you didnt even give us one.
2. Fix MAJOR holes in the sory, show us the clues we analyzed for years werent some bullshit to extend the show.

and if these two simple fucking things were fixed noone in their right mind would be fucking ready to kill you right now Heller.

If I was Simon Baker I would tell you to suck my fucking balls and to quit because obviously you are a money grabbing piece of shit and Simon is above that lame ass dick sucker. Dont bite the hand that feeds you dickhead. and you sir have done it because we feed you. we keep this show going just so we can waste fucking 6 years for nothing. a shit reveal of the gayest character on the list! beside reede smith.

Now i know you said on an interview people would be dissapointed no matter who it was. well guess what you guaranteed it now cock face. Fuck you Bruno Fuck you Mcalister pathetic!

Go the Mentalist! Fire BH love you Simon Baker! <3

woooh,

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The reason why Patrick offered his "back" / "shoulder" to FBI agent to sign the letters is to gauge the pen pressure. It seems Patrick will learn how he signs and will copy it on a legal document.

Perhaps that's the reason, why he asks FBI agent to sign multiple times!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

For all the people saying clues don't add up, here are some facts.

1. McAllister is not middle-aged: according to the Collins Dictionary middle-age means this is "[...] usually considered to occur approximately between the ages of 41 and 60" and since Xander Berkeley is 55 years old, this argument is invalid

2. It doesn't fit Rosalind description (first part): Rosalind stated that RJ was "just under six feet" (which I doubt she measured with a measuring tape), and since Xander is 6 feet tall and considering that it was an approximation this is an invalid argument

3. It doesn't fit Rosalind description (second part): Rosalind stated that he has straight hair (which McAllister has), but some of you are protesting because he is semi-bald, although those are two independent statements I will play along; So, he is semi-bald, but was him when Rosalind met him?, I mean at the beginning of the show (5 years ago) he wasn't.


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Just seen the promo for next week... So the show is now a slap stick comedy with silly music...are they deliberately trying to can the entire franchise??? Can anyone else recall a show changing so quickly and so badly?

Er... I'm trying to start us off with an example... Struggling to name one that is comparable...

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I dont care that it turned out to be McAllister. Im looking forward to Jane working with the FBI and abbot and the new lady.

I hope Lisbon, Rigsby and Van Pelt don't return to the series. Chou, Abbot, FBI-lady can stay

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I can't believe what some people are saying about Red John begging for mercy.
Most serialkillers are cowardly bastards, same goes for Red John, where you expecting some kind of a evil superhero?
I think the episode show his true colors well.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

What the fuck is going on? I can;t believe they ended the Red John story this way...the show was Red John....they could have done so much and made it epic but I'm speechless ..it's like they just pulled a name out of a hat   if you're gonna do that make it someone not on the list or if it's someone back from the dead fake out have it be Partridge or Stiles or even Haffner  all of whom would have been a better Red John  it's just done so fuckin sloppy like all of a sudden Heller and Baker don't give a fuck anymore   Red John's afraid of birds? cries like a fuckin bitch? calls 911???   They should have ended this season with the Red John identity reveal and the 7th and final season is the Hunt for Red John and the series ends with Red John's death       still the Red John fan in me still believes that McAllister isn't the real Red John and it's still open for a Red John return just like Timothy Carter        THERE'S NO FUCKIN WAY THIS IS HOW IT'S ALL GONNA END NO FUCKIN WAY     THE SHOW'S FUCKIN DONE     The Red John storyline brought a dramatic tension to the show that raised it above most dramas on network t.v. and without that it's just another boring cop procedural like bones or castle       holy fuckin shit  Heller just jumped the shark right off a cliff while Simon Baker is fucking him in the ass      I hope Baker had fun directing episode 9.....fuckin pretentious cunt     "i'm sick of the Red John storyline I want to dance on the beach and then after talking to a woman for the first time I''m gonna give up moving on with my life and go back to an even worst situation than before" it's the same show just Jane is working for the FBI       oh ya and one more thing   JANE DISARMS RED JOHN WITH A FUCKIN PIGEON??? I was ok with the McAllister reveal till then          EPISODE 8 IS UP THERE WITH PHANTOM MENACE AND LOST for WHAT THE FUCK ?????               

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on