Who is Red John?

Theory #6312 • by IKnowWhoRedJohnIs7

Suspect

Walter Mashburn

Walter Mashburn
Suspected in 325 theories

ARGUMENTATION

Just a little comment about the fixation on "the list" of 7.  Jane did not have this list (to our knowledge).  He handed 7 pictures to Lisbon, which matched up against the names Lorelei read on the DVD AFTER Jane had already seen it.  So he just gave her the pictures of Red John's list.  Jane never made that list.  He would never have made that list.  He only met Kirkland and Smith AFTER Lorelei told him he had shaken hands with RJ, so there is no way that Jane would have included those two on a list of his suspects.  Plenty of reasons to exclude all of the others, but those two are irrefutable.  The list of 7 is bogus.  The real list is the little notebook that we saw earlier in the season the Jane always keeps with him.

And Bruno Heller did NOT say that Red John is on the list of 7.  He said "you can trust the list."  He didn't say which list, or what the list was a list of (accomplices, maybe).  So don't fixate on this list folks. 

How do you find this theory?
plausible
unlikely
comments powered by Disqus
Follow us on