Who is Red John?

Theory #11303 • by NatBrasil

Suspect

Gale Bertram

Gale Bertram
Suspected in 460 theories

ARGUMENTATION

Hello, everyone!

Firstly, i'd like to say that i would be
disappointed if McAllister were RJ, because his charater changed a lot
since episode "Red hair and silver tape". I mean, i didn't even
recognized him this season, i thought that he was portraited by another
actor, not Xander Berkeley.

Ok, now, let's go to the main point:
se.05 ep. 22 - "Red John's Rules". When Lisbon is talking to Jane about
who was Aileen Turner/Leelee Barlow, Lisbon told Jane abou HER happy
memory, it was: Lisbon's mother feeding pigeons at the park,
related to the song "MacArthur Park" (a cake left out in the rain).
After that, in episode 06x02, "Red-winged black bird", there's that
scene with Lisbon and Jane at that park and a strange woman feeding pigeons.

So,
reading this song lyrics, it refers to a cake that take so long to bake
(it reminds me Sophie's head in the oven). But i can't find something
really interesting in this lyrics.
But (!!!!!!) the pigeons are
important references. Since Red John was in a house full of pigeons when
he "killed" Brett Partridge, how could RJ be Sheriff McAllister, if
he's afraid of birds?

Regards from Brasil!!!

How do you find this theory?
plausible
unlikely
comments powered by Disqus
Follow us on