Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Unrevealed suspect

Unrevealed suspect
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

Ok,
call me crazy, but here it goes some thoghts of mine:

 

 I
think Stiles and Haffner ran away PJ’s house, so Stiles could be free of FBI
surveillance and lead PJ to RJ. Haffner went away with Stiles in order to
protect him.


About
McAllister, I really don’t know what heppened to him.


The
only people who declaim a poem by William Blake are: RJ, Kimbal Cho and Gale
Bertram... Besides Brett Partridge knowing about a book  by Charles Dickens (watch the first 10
minutes of episode 5x15 – Red lacquer nail polish).

I
mean, Bertram, Stiles and Partridge seems to be the most intelectual of the
suspects, and i was hoping RJ is an intelectual person as well.


BUT,
i learned that the word “pigeon”, besides name a bird (dove), also is a slang
for a naive person (my native language is portuguese). The most naive suspect
is McAllister... What about the pigeons appearing so much this season?



 

I
don’t know anything anymore. I wanted RJ to be Bertram, but not like this...





Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

look at RJ left hand (sec 20) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DcvSrUR0NJw, there is a gold ring right ? ok look this http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uBepaOq3Vrw - Shawn Barlow is RJ


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

and this years special teen choice
award goes to

bretty-must have faked-his-death-
-partridge.
for his role as the most misunderstood character in tv show history,
poor victim of zombie brainwashed teen theorists.

and if partridge won t be
the one who gets strangled by pj next episode, never mind - still some more
episodes to go. we already had jane kill a fake red john, do not worry.

go on observing 666 pidgeons
and stuff, everything s possible in tv wonderland. Though it might be a bit delusional
- one might think

 




Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

This one seems pretty legit, think it's pretty much what's going on.http://www.whoisredjohn.com/See-a-theory-Red-John/12033

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

oh I just read that the guy whistling when Reeded= was spilliing his guts was Kirkland. Lol Heller is messing with us. He is making it seem like everyone is potentially Red John. My Head is wrecked with guessing 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Where's the option of choosing " NOT AN EFFING CLUE" !

To answer a question below the site here is really slow and sometimes doesn't work I'm guessing it's because the amount of people on here increased last night.

I don't think it's mcallistor in the promo. 

Crap theory of the day :
Maybe they swopped Partridges DNA on the system with someone elses, removed the flesh part of his tattoo and left the flesh in the explosion. Maybe I'm talking out of my arse.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Well, this episode just continued the trend of season 6 so far.
Eliminate one suspect on the list after another, until no one is left.
So RJ could basically be ANYONE.

If we take the list:
Partidge: dead (but we never saw the face of the body, Cho inspected)
Kirkland: dead (for sure, but what about the twin brother?)
Stiles,
McAllister, Haffner: dead (but not confirmed?, only thing we saw was
their pictures on the wall and a foot on the ground at the scene. Jane,
Smith and Bertram survived, so why not someone else?)
Smith: in custody
Bertram: alive, on the run.

So it is Bertram, right? Well, no. Bertram wanted to kill Jane, because he knew about Tyger, Tyger.
PJ is driven by his hate for RJ. He wants to take revenge. Jane wants to
kill RJ, not have him arrested. So why tell the media RJs identity, so
that every law enforcement agency is on the manhunt for him? Right, he
wouldn't. He wants Bertram arrested, because he is a high ranking member
of Tyger, tyger.

So where does that leave us?
I really, don't know, but there is still a major plot hole, that hasn't been revealed.
What about the gunshot before the explosion and the explosion itself.
Who fired a gun? Was anyone shot?
And
who set of the bomb? If it was RJ, why would he set up an explosion,
while being in the room? He would have to calculate a possibility of
dying himself, by doing such a thing/ And suicide sounds nothing like
anything RJ would do.
So the assumption would be, that RJ was not in the room.
So
that leaves a couple of dead persons (Partridge, Kirkland, the twin,
even Bosco [they showed his dead again, shot in the ribcage, a shot you
could survive...], or the new detective or Mashburn or.., or...).

I
am not going to make a pick here, because throughout the show I have
been 100% certain to know who RJ is so many times (from Stiles to La
Roche to Partridge to Haffner and back and so on) and one episode away from the reveal, I am clueless again.

Who
I want it to be: Partridge, because Jack Plotnick is a terrific actor
and portrayed Partridge the way I would imagine RJ to be. Highly
intelligent, skilled and icredibly creepy. But it is so very unlikely he is still alive and RJ.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on