Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

I haven't ever posted on here, but I have been thinking about the season finale and I thought of a theory. What if Jane and Lisbon are putting on a show? They have done it before. Why else would Lisbon's freak out moment be so cheesy? Also, she was pushing Jane to say what he felt, but then she freaks out on him when he tries to do it in his own way? The whole love thing between them was cheesy so i'm wondering if Jane and Lisbon are just putting on a show for someone. Cho has been with them the whole time and he doesn't see the whole love thing but Abbott does. Cho knew about Grace and Rigsby when they were sneaking around. Maybe they're playing the FBI, I mean, who knows what Jane and Lisbon were talking about when they were writing letters.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Fuck you, fuck you, fuck you...your cool...fuck you.  I'm out.

H IS M.  a part of me died a little when I saw that.  

But it was cute. If I totally ignore my EXPECTATIONS and HOPES and DREAMS, it was cute.  

The H IS M bit might mean that the joke has been on us all along.  And if that is the case, then fine.  I'll take it.  

What do you make of the H IS M thing?

BTW...that dewey decimal clue was not that easy, right?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I know red john is dead and he is never coming back but i remember red john saying i have a friend in the fbi that was never explained if they were caught or who It was it would be nice to see some off red johns old friends that could explain certain questions that were not answered i mean timothy carter who was not red john let us know what the daughter smelled like as she was being murdered that would be nice

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Well, I may be the delusional one on the board here but I'm glad to see The Mentalist back for another season.  Of course, I have no expectations of getting a Red John recap or explanation next season but I do hope they tie up a few things with the flash drive.  The way I look at it the encrypted drive could open a whole new quest for Jane that may keep the season watch-worthy.

As for next weeks "romantic episode" .......Heller stated a couple weeks back that the ending was made as a finale AND/ OR a new beginning.  Since I really don't believe they will have Jane and Lisbon as a couple next year I'm betting that...........

Lisbon's decision to stay will be based on her realization that she is NOT IN LOVE WITH PIKE.  Remember guys... Jane is a Mentalist.  He will somehow get Lisbon to admit she's not ready to move with Pike while at the same time confess the fact he wants her stay and let him redeem himself.  Viola...... season 7 opens with Jane doing something stupid...Lisbon getting pissed and we have a whole season of angst and unrequited sexual tension for the Jisbon-y fangirls out there.

At least this will give Cho some awkward one-liners.  Heh.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Well, Red John''s return is looking more and more slim.

Just saw an interview with Heller regarding the show being renewed. He reiterated Red John was McAllister and the characted is indeed NOT part of the show.

Heller stated:

"We know some folks think the Red John ending could have been different, but the show was not about him. We wanted to give Jane closure on his family's murder so he can focus on being a mentalist. That is what the show is about"




Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I saw on the news that the show has been renewed.

What can I say?  People hoping for Jisbon will now have to contend with a season ending without a definite answer on the relationship, and endure through a whole season next year to see them get together, break up and then perhaps make up for the show's finale.

Yeah!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on