Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

Two goofs in the one church sounds like a bad joke. Tweedle dum and tweendle dee. 

The scenes were boring. I feel like I know the layout of that whole area.No need for a paper map for me. They showed so much of it. It just really really sucked. They lost imagination completely.

Some parts of Sheriff were okay...just okay though. He would have been a good red john with a better feel to the episode in a different situation with different props and a different leadup and maybe a complete different producer but mostly falling through things and staggering around the place, he just liked like a grandad old and haggered and there was no suspense.

To be honest Bertram  JUST BY A MARGIN had more balls then Red John. They should have left the really good actors ( no offence I just mean the better ones) till the end.  Mcdowell would have been fantastic! Even Haffner scared the crap outta me at times. The whole thing was just wrong wrong wrong wrong. 

I don't understand it.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

It was the worst episode I have ever seen! Shit, shit, shit, shiiiiit! The producers and writers humiliated us! They really fucked the Red John story as well! Bruno Heller and his team goes to hell and suck each others cock!

We are faithful viewers, did we deserves that auwful Red John story ends? No way!

Where is fucking Heller earlier promises? Where is the criminal mastermind Red John?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Nobody was expecting this ending, so, one point to Heller. I liked it. McAllister and PJ are not superhumans, they are just very clever people, but they can fail. McAllister, together with Partridge, are the only supects that perform their first appearance in the first season. Mc is the one who best fits with the "he is mar" clue and the smell of pines... And he has appeared a lot of times in the series, remember, he is RJ. Timothy Carter was a bad fake RJ who came from nowhere explaining nothing and everybody was OK with it. I didn't like him. Mc, as leader of the BA, explains how RJ had a lot of accomplices. We don't know what crimes committed himself and wich ones committed his accomplices. This explains many things and keeps some mystery. About the voice... Everybody can fake different voices, like Bruce Wayne... I like the show moving forward.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I have seen less running in a marathon. Jesus, nearly every scene was running...wow what action....oh brother

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

jimmy gadd posted on his twitter account  that the leaked link was the unfinished show of the    episode that will air on sunday .

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

These were the 7 steps to Red John Anonymous before we seen the episode air: The bold is the new steps that were amended after we watched the episode.
 
1.We admit that we are powerless over who Red John is-  that our lives had become unmanageable with trying to guess.We admit that we are powerless over this ridiculous Red John episode-  that our lives had become unmanageable with trying to accept it as a genuine Red John Reveal.

2. We believe that a Power greater than ourselves can restore us to sanity ( After we find out who Red John is) .We make a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of Heller as we understood Him NEVER.He then fucked us over with nothing that resembles red john. That was the worst mistake of our lives. We are all assholes by putting our faith in him.

3.We make a searching and fearless moral inventory of Red John Suspects, .Admitted to God, to ourselves and to another mentalist followers the exact nature of our wrong guesses.
We are entirely ready to have Heller  remove all these defects of wrong character guesses.
We humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings. Ha Ha DID we really do this. OUR SHORTCOMINGS. HA HA HA

4. We make a list of all persons Red John has harmed, and became willing to make  resurrected psychopathic serial killers of them all.  We Make direct amends to such accused people wherever possible... every two minutes, except when to do so would not agree with the list or increase their height or decrease the amount of hair they have.  Our theories were far better then the explainations we got. Trust in ourselves more often.

5. We still continued to take character inventory and when we are wrong promptly admit before changing our minds yet again. Never expect anything more then ONE BADLY EXPLAINED TWIST.

6. We sought through meditation and twitter to improve our conscious contact with Heller as we  never understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for Red John and the power to carry that out his character effectively and satisfactory. NONE OF THESE THINGS WERE ACHIEVED.

7.Having had a absolutely no spiritual awakening as the result of these steps, we try to carry this message to all Red John Anonymous members and to practice these principles in all our affairs. WE try to carry the message not to get hopes up too high as this episode is a complete disappointment and couldn't be worse.


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Even if they made an extra episode explaining everything that they missed just to please fans it still wouldn't matter because RED JOHN IS DEAD. The most boring uneventful death of all time.
That was probably his mother protecting him with the knife. Jane did say on the TV that he was most likely living with his mother or his sister in a bungalow...anyway where was I'am getting off the track of stupidity...

The episode has come and gone, there is no making up for this. I mean on the Hitler video it asked about it being on a DVD. WHAT!
I'M NOT EVEN GOING TO BUY THE BLOODY DVD and FUND HELLER AND HIS ABOMINATION. NEVER. 

This is a three minute youtube video and there is more talent in this video then the whole mentalist put together  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kmP4Xzt0rN4&list=FLr7AHSWpLR-Jqez2-Dsqu3Q&index=3

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on