Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

Finally RJ comes face to face with PJ and the battle is for justice! RJ is revealed ..!!
the serial killer finally is dead ! RJ is dead! Thomas McAllister is dead THOMAS McAllister IS RED JOHN !! A mystery comes to an end .. bruno heller amazing job! see episode 8 season 6 again and again!! 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

What irks me is that none of the clues from the first five season were addressed. It's like none of that mattered at all. All of the seemingly important clues, mistakes, etc have any impact or importance on anything. They took something millions of people were covering closely and developing theories on and think it's enough to simply reveal and not explain.

Jane explains his tricks, what he knew, and the criminals' mistakes in virtually every non-red john episode, but decides not to explain any of this on the biggest mystery of the entire show?! I'm not upset with the character selected, but if you develop a 'smart' show for a 'smart' audience, don't act shocked when the show gets criticized for leaving almost everything people have been wondering about from prior seasons just dangling out there. You could probably explain "he is mar", Visualize, the farm, Rosalind Harker, and several other lingering questions in 1-2 episodes then move on and satisfy everyone, why not do this?

It's like if "Law and Order" just ended with the judge saying guilty each week rather than going through the court portion, there needs to be an explanation on motive, connections, etc.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I just can't believe this! This closure for RJ Case is one of the biggest disappointments and scandals in TV history without doubt. Such a cheap, lazy, awful, ridiculous episode! Actually, I
must have been very surprised after the episode because of its
brilliance instead of having been surprised about its being a joke or
not. I'm so pissed off..

 This episode is a complete insult to the fans!

-Even RJ's entering the scene is a total mess and so sudden! First of all, we could have heard his voice or seen his shadow before he fully appears. That would arouse excitement more but all of a sudden, we see Sheriff!

-A
big bad and master killer like RJ is begging Jane for his life! Bruno Heller ruined such a good character he has been built for six years in a few minutes. Besides, RJ feels sorry for Jane's family! Complete nonsense and bullshit! That kind of character never feels sorry and prefers dying instead of getting arrested.This is unbelievable! This is unacceptable. I can't believe that Bruno Heller wrote the episode. You
ruined this show Bruno Heller. I'm sorry but the truth hurts.

- Let's say we got over the fact that RJ turned out to be Sheriff. Xander Berkeley is a really good actor but you're giving him a few cheap dialogues Bruno! He also runs faster than Jane though being wounded. Jane is like a turtle! Bruno even can't use Xander Berkeley for this role, which had a real chance to become a cult but the show missed that opportunity.

- For the past six years, we've been waiting a
flashback about RJ's past but no! RJ character was sent off without
having been introduced to the viewers enough!.RJ character should have been explained and detailed completely before getting killed. Also, the clues throughout six seasons weren't explained. I wanted to hear them from RJ
himself and in that "big" confrontation! What a weak and childish confrontation! That must have been with high tension and in a cool way for both characters! What a pity! I still can't
believe! This must be a joke..They could have used great flashbacks for RJ's murders or preparations for murders and tricks just like "Saw" movie. Damn it, Bruno! Were you drunk while writing the episode?

- A man like Jane can't understand that the woman in the church is RJ's accomplice for a long time.

-RJ is entering a home, breaking glasses while running! What a ridiculous situation for these final moments of RJ!

- I wish 3rd season finale would've been the closure of
RJ Case...That was the best episode in the whole show! Clever, exciting, tricky, shocking and well-written.

- A real "Mentalist" fan can't have really liked this closure for RJ Case.

- Now , this show needs a better-written big bad than RJ and
it must not last for 4-5 seasons...

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

FROM IMBD
Things we learned from the mentalist
12. When all else fails beg for your life like a little girl.
13, Pigeons can hold their breath for a really long time.
14. Red John ran track before he was shot in the gut.
15. Killing Red John is really homoerotic.
16. The clues don't matter.
Please add more...

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

  "Hey, Rocky, watch me pull a rabbit out of my hat." Rocky: "A-gain ... Actually I am going to pull a pigeon out of my... Red Jon looks on in horror!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Pigeons > Red John Reveal

Don't forget to order your Pigeon shirt here ->>http://teespring.com/PIGEON

Only 23 left :D

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on