Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

Come on guys it's over. I don't like that it is McAllsiter and I respect your opinions but how long will you keep accusing other suspects!?!? ESPECIALLY Partridge! The guy is dead 7 episodes from now and people keep accusing him.
When will this ever stop? I'm betting there will be people accusing BP even when the show is over. Get Over It.
YES the RJ reveal was lame (to most of us) but it is what it is and the show must go on. There will be a twist over the next episodes and this is what the shows ratings will rely on.
RJ is over.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Even though Red John is dead, his disciples and the Blake Association are still out there. Will we hear from them again?
Heller: I never say never, but I would say I think the audience and the story demands that we step away from that trope for a while. The trouble with these sorts of stories where you're playing tricks on the audience, with who-is-it mysteries, is you can get way too mysterious. There are people who said all the way along that Patrick Jane is Red John. When you've got that kind of elaborate thinking out there, it's dangerous to come back to that story unless you're coming back full force, because then maybe will start thinking, "Oh, maybe Red John's not dead." Red John is dead. 

http://blog.zap2it.com/frominsidethebox/2013/11/the-mentalist-after-red-john-then-what-simon-baker-c...

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I am from thailand so I can't watch the real ep.
I've just watched the leak ep.
Could you please tell me is it the same one by
hit green if it's the same
and hit red if it's not the same.
THANK YOU

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

"I have a dream! And in that dream Heller will cut the nonsense crap and give us explanations about Red John's past!"

Its a real shame! Ok, McAllister is a good Red John, a sheriff would have the freedom to come and go without anyone asking what he was doing, etc. Xander Berkeley is and amazing actor but the script for "Red John" episode is just lame.

I was madly angry when i read the interview that says Heller only decided who was Red John a couple of years ago. So ALL THOSE YEARS we were chasing NOTHING! There was NO RED JOHN! Not even Heller knew who he was! That's is fuc**!@# ... ¬¬ 

The scene when McAllister says "Its totally fair. The game is over and i won", i kinda raped the REPLAY, i just started to laugh, SIMON BAKER's voice in Xander Berkley, a shit dubbing. It was more than anything funny hahahaha.. 

So.. we know who is Red John, finally, but we also have NO IDEIA of WHO is Red John, if you know that i mean, there was 0 explanations. What about the SHOT on Patrick's house? Was that the concussion bomb? Did i miss anything? .__. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The story of Red John is over. Look at the episode titles. Every episode up to this one has a title with something to do with the colour red but now the episodes are titled so that the colour Red is not mentioned. this tells me that the show is moving on from Red John.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Best/Worst moment ever

"The game is over and I won" 

Hahahahahah what the fuck was that hahaha

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The problem with the Red John episode is fans of the show care about the clues and want answers to certain questions, i.e. He is Mar, what happened to Kristina Frye, Rosalind Harker description of Red John, Sophie Millers description of Red John but Patrick Jane doesn't care, he found Red John and killed him, like he said he was going to do.

So the show couldn't reconcile what the fans wanted and what Jane wanted (or didn't want, for example he doesn't care how Red John knew his list of 7 suspects). 

So the show pulled itself apart in my opinion.

As far as Xander Berkeley, he's a good actor, he would have been a great Red John 10 years ago when he was playing George Mason on 24, Sophie Miller described RJ as middle aged, I think 57 is a bit old, mid 40's would have worked better for me, but here I am speaking as a fan, and Patrick Jane doesn't care how old RJ is.

I did like the way he killed RJ, could have lead to the moment a little better but I'll forgive it that.   


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on