Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

That Red Lutz is even crazier than Stoopkid, who at least is not rude.

What a moron thing to say: "if you think Red John is dead then don't come to this website". Well I'm sorry but some people want to talk about what's happening on the show after Red John's death. Yes, the website's name is Who is Red John because when it started we didn't know who Red John was. Now we know so the website's name doesn't matter anymore.
This page should be about the show now not 'who is Red John'. I bet in 5 years time some people here will still be sure that RJ was Rigsby or Van Pelt or whatever.

Red  John was Sheriff Thomas McAllister, the sheriff of Napa County, portrayed by Xander Berkeley whether you like it or not!
Lol, why is it so hard to accept now that the whole show has moved on!?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

So many people still expecting the show to somehow erase the damage done by the 10 or so episodes this season.  They eagerly wait for a dream sequence, a coma, or another sort of deus ex machina trick to forgive all.

Well, here is how you will know what happens next in the show.  All you need is to understand two things:

First, it is easy to hook the audience with wild clues that are all over the map, if you have no idea what the ending is going to be like.  If you have no clue, and especially no desire to tie things up at the end, you can make things up as you go along because there really is nothing holding you back.  Furthermore, each new twist or "clue" only makes the show that much more exciting.  There are many examples of this from the X Files to the Lost.

Second, you must realize that the Mentalist has been copying other shows, notably Profiler and Dexter, pretty liberally and literally:

1) In Dexter, two main characters are a blonde male (Dexter) and a dark-haired, non-traditionally beautiful woman (his sister Deb).  The Mentalist has the same characters, in physical appearance, in PJ and Lisbon.

2) In Dexter, a character says: "there is a storm coming your way."  In Mentalist, this becomes, "there is a comeuppance headed (PJ's) way."  Not only this but even the timing of the above sentence are almost identical in the final sequence of the episodes.

3) In Dexter, Deb gets attacked from behind and gets pulled down.  In the Mentalist, Lisbon suffers this attack.  If you watch the clip, I guarantee your jaw will drop and you will end up muttering a few choice profanities at the Mentalist.  If you are interested, it is Dexter's season 7, episode 3, named "Buck The System."  Just watch from 49-51 minutes in the show.

4) In Dexter, a woman comes on the show out of nowhere when Dexter seems to be in most trouble.  While she appears to be an adversary, she proves to be helpful to Dexter and she paves the way for the show's finale.  In the Mentalist, this plot is copied almost identically and carried out by Lorelei Martins.

5) Dexter is a bad (good) guy.  So, the series ending cannot be copied directly.  Here, the great writers of the Mentalist turn to Profiler and copy the exact disclosure of the villain: a small town sheriff is the bad guy.  (See the first point above about not caring to tie all the past clues.)

So, how do you know what will happen next in the show?  Well, it is going to be just like your other favorite show, of course!  The one that is on cable now or the one that was canceled a few years ago!


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Bruno Heller: "A lot of people will be disapointed by the reveal of Red John"

AMAGAD HELLER HAS PSYCHIC POWERS!!!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I REALLY HATE TO BE LIKE THIS BUT DO ANY OF YOU HAVE A LIFE? YOU ARE TREATING THIS RED JOHN THING LIKE IT IS REAL? ITS A SHOW, GET OVER IT AND MOVE ON. I CANNOT BELIEVE YOU PEOPLE HAVE THIS MUCH TIME ON YOUR HANDS. IF YOUR A GUY, THEN GET A JOB OR GET A GIRLFRIEND BECAUSE THIS IS PATHETIC. YOU SHOULD READ THE THINGS YOU WRITE ON HERE AND WASTE YOUR LIFE ABOUT. IT IS OBVIOUS NOBODY ON THIS SITE IS FROM THE NORTHEAST COAST BECAUSE YOU WOULD HAVE TOO MUCH TO DO. I'M GUESS MOST PEOPLE ARE FROM EITHER THE SOUTH OR MIDWEST. GET A LIFE MOVE ON PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

In an episode from season 4, to prove he was alive to everyone RJ killed a morgue attendant who FBI agent Darcy spoke to, Rosland said that Roy had visited her - and Jane and everyone found a the dead body of the attendant in the closet.

Also Harker states that Roy told her to pass on a message to Jane, can't remember what it was but it was clear that it was from RJ.

Simple. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Stoopkid

Why did the RJ leave a body at her house then ?

Rosland was RJ's girlfriend, there is no need to doubt it, what possible reason would there be ?

We saw RJ on the farm, behind the door Jane almost opened and running away from the house.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

To Stoopkid

You said in a comment that there was no evidence Rosland Harker was ever with RJ.

Yes there is.

Sheriff Dumar confirms it, " Red John was a friend of my fathers," ect.

And the fact RJ dumped the body of the morgue attendant there in season 4.


Cheers 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on