Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Ray Haffner

Ray Haffner
Suspected in 875 theories

THE THEORIES

I would like nothing more than a dead GVP, a blood painting we know all too well, and a thoroughly defeated Jane.

I would also say the kidnapping of GVP is a lure for Jane (read the next episode summary), but wouldn't Lisbon's disappearance be a stronger motivation? Then again, we all know how lackluster the writers have been since the Mcallister fiasco. But then, if none of this is for Jane, what is the point of all this? I hardly think anyone would go to such lengths just to kill Rigsby.

Regardless of what might actually have happened at Jane's house, as far as we know, Reede Smith is still alive. I still think the more likely candidates are Stiles or Haffner, and out of the two of them, Haffner being most likely. You have to remember the beginning of this season, when the quality of writing was at its peak, Red John kidnapped Lisbon and left her intact, painting his smiley with Partridge's blood almost lovingly on her face. AFAIK, Red John does not leave survivors if he can help it, Jane being the obvious exception since he had more planned for him, and Haffner has shown deep feelings for Lisbon, which could have influenced this. Also, it appears Haffner/Stiles/Visualize did hire Kira Tinsley, possibly to plant the dotted tattoo clue to mislead Jane. The funny thing is, the way Jane is acting so far, it seems like he truly believes he has killed Red John.

Someone on Jane's list is Red John, but it was never Mcallister. At this point, everyone can see the different details that poke holes in the whole "RJ = Mcallister" thing. We can only hope.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Ray Haffner is killing former CBI members.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Anyone else ever feel like we the fans are Patrick Jane and Heller is Red John calling us on the phone
after each episode since ' Fire and Brim?'
We pick up and on the other end of the line, we hear Heller laughing at us?!?

Reminds me of the time Red John called Jane at the scene of Jared Renfrew's murder and the hooker's murder in 'Red John's Friends.'
The episode ended with Jane picking up the phone and Red John laughing devilishly into the phone.

Bingo.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Where did it all go wrong? Are they even trying to thread these episodes together anymore? I fear that even should they try to tie it all up now (which i'm not convinced they will) that they have just left too many loose ends that the real fans could not possibly be satisfied. It's almost like the scriptwriters have left the show for other work now and put the interns in charge. They still follow the weekly killing recipe but any overarching theme or 'shadow' is painfully missing, Ardilles' killing was the only thing of interest that has happened since the Red John reveal fiasco and if anything it seems like it was shoe-horned in inappropriately, like a grisly scene accidentally put into an episode of Murder She Wrote or Diagnosis Murder.

I for one am losing interest in the show and am only still here out of (misplaced) loyalty and the fact that I still secretly have hope that they are long-conning us and are going to turn it around. I am fast losing that hope though.

Why didn't the FBI investigate Ardilles' murder? Isn't he as important as the lawyer in the last episode? Why didn't Jane take an interest in it? Why is it down to Rigby and Van Pelt - two private detectives- to investigate out of self-interest?

And don't even get me started on the unanswered questions of the Red John reveal. It was tied up so badly that it MUST be a con. Mustn't it?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Cho actually Smiled!!!!!!! Now that was a pleasant surprise. :-D First good thing to happen in a while.
Mexican jumping beans are pretty cool.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hi Mentalist
Fans,



Anyone want to read a new lengthy post? I spend a lot of time on this just because I was curious! :) I was just doing it for my own research and curiosity but it occurred to me that some fans might be interested in seeing this. So, it's not an actual theory, but mostly a list that may or may not have any significance depending on how you view it. (and on how Heller & Co. wrote it and meant it).

So what I did was compiled a
list of names/words/phrases that could be possible drug references in The Mentalist, because I wanted to see how many
could be found and if it would reveal any insight into the show.


Keeping in mind that many of us are familiar with the show's story lines that often center around drugs and many drug references in the show, I wanted to see what I could find from a little digging.

*This drug list isn't for pointing to an actual suspect, but if you are curious as to why I think Red John is a certain suspect, I provided some comments on that at the end.

From the research
I’ve done, it may be possible that Red John and possibly Visualize, are the
heads of huge DRUG RINGS. Maybe the Blake Association works for them and
recruits people who will work for the BA because of their shady pasts or if
they made a mistake and need it cleaned up (ex: Reed Smith) so they do things
they don’t want to do for Red John in order to escape jail time.

I’m sure there
is even more to the drug story line, but I’ll get right to the list to save time.

Just thought
I’d share what I found with all of you regarding the drug references in case
you are interested
On some of
these I was surprised and said, What? WOW!  ;-)  Even if you don't agree, at least it's another post to read if you are longing for more Mentalist info. There was more I could have posted, but it's long enough as it is.Even if it doesn't end up being what Heller intended, I still found it VERY interesting!

I have no idea if any of this is relevant so please don't take it as I think every single word is a definite clue. I just wanted to see how many I could find that may be POSSIBLE clues from the writers. With that in mind, hope you have fun with it! :)

SOURCES used:
1) http://www.noslang.com/drugs/dictionary/p/


2) www.urbandictionary.com           


3) http://onlineslangdictionary.com/thesaurus/words+meaning+drugs.html


4) http://casapalmera.com/top-20-drugs-and-their-street-names/

POSSIBLE DRUG REFERENCES  in The Mentalist:

1)   
Tiger = HEROIN



2)    Tiger, Tiger= Heroin, Heroin (ride
the tiger=inject heroin, psychedelic consciousness after injecting
hallucinogenic drugs)




3)    White Tiger = Cocaine



4)    Red John (Jack slang for John) = to steal
someone else’s drugs



5)    Red=under the influence of drugs



6)    Red BOOK- =100 dosage units of LSD



7) (red)   John (Jack)-to steal someone’s drugs 

8)    Fire & Brimstone = Crack Cocaine,
Meth




9)    Pumping (iron) =Selling Crack



10) PAT
JANE (Patrick Jane) = Marijuana, Marijuana




11) Spider = Heroin



12) Tea=Marijuana,
phencyclidine




13)***3
DOTS=LSD, drug trafficker, Line of cocaine, 3 Dots on shoulders could signify
being a drug trafficker. Blake Association, Tiger Tiger, could be code for
Heroin.



14) Dove
(Pigeon)= $35 worth of of cocaine – 1 oz of crack cocaine

15) Dove
(Pigeon) eating seeds out of hands or on ground=taking a drug orally




16) Bird
seeds- marijuana




17) Smiley
Face= Cocaine  Happy Face= Cocaine

18) Tiger,
Tiger –handsome, beautiful, seductive killer and/or drug dealer (Red John)




19) Lamb-could
signify Red John’s followers and victims. Following with the drug theme, his
followers could be addicted to him and to the drugs and Highs he provides. Drug
addicts will do often do anything for a fix. They will give up their families,
steal, are beholden to their dealers and feel they owe them. Drug dealers are
manipulators. Drugs steal your life. They make you someone you are really not.
Lambs/Addicts are led to the slaughter by their tigers.



20) Grey
Water= Grey Blunts, PCP, GHB, methamphetamine

21) Black
Helicopters= marijuana, opium, methamphetamine, CONSPIRACY THEORIES

22) White
Lines-Cocaine, heroin, methamphetamine lines




23) Golden
Hammer- marijuana cigarettes




24) White
as the driven snow-cocaine, heroin, amphetamine




25)  Green
Thumb- inferior quality marijuana, big joint the size of a thumb



26) (My)Blue
heaven- LSD, hallucinogen, depressants, oxycotin, crack cocaine



27) Hubba Pigeons (white dove) – MDMA (ecstasy), crack users looking for rocks (drugs) on
the floor after a police raid




28) Birdhead-LSD



29) Birdie
powder-cocaine, heroin



30) Hunter-cocaine



31) Red
& Blue-depressants (red-under influence of drugs)




32) White-coke



33) ROLL
TIDE- Uttered after dipping tea into water. Riding the wave of drugs.  Under influence of drugs. Signifies victory
in face of extreme adversity. To experience the effects of ecstasy.


34) Belladonna-PCP



35) Sniff-cocaine
up nose



36) Snow-cocaine,
heroin




37) Black-marijuana,
opium, meth



38) Pot-marijuana.
Also Haffner means pot or dish. Could be double meaning.



39) Haffner
is whistling,”Jimmy Crack Corn” as he leaves Lisbon’s hospital room. “Crack
Corn” is a rock solid form of cocaine. Years ago, makeshift crack pipes were
made from hollowed out corn cobs and it was called “cracking corn.”




40) Patrick
Jane’s eyes are dilated through each episode. = sign of being under hypnosis or
on drugs. Could be subplot of where Patrick Jane really is. (Ex: in mental
hospital imagining all of what is going on)



41) VERY INTERESTING:  In
the episode, Red John, Jane’s wife and daughter are listed in the credits as
being in Jane’s “hallucination.” Then the next episode is titled, My Blue
Heaven, which refers to LSD, a hallucinogenic drug.

That makes it a reasonable
theory that Jane may have ended up in a coma or is still suffering from a
hallucinogen after the blast and the audience hasn’t seen or been told who
really died in the blast (if anyone) or if the blast even happened or who Red
John really is.

OTHER THOUGHTS:
 
Since
they never showed us the bodies of Haffner or Stiles and "said" they were dead...(but then again they originally said MacAllister was dead and he turned up alive)   
then just abandoned the story and zoomed
ahead 2 years (how convenient) It never made sense that the suspects would meet
Jane on his terms, at a time and place he dictated, not knowing what Jane
really wanted, especially when they were not friends with Jane.

 It also makes absolutely NO SENSE the suspects would go there unarmed (with a SECOND gun on their leg or somewhere else on their body) we didn't see Jane pat them down and look for other weapons.  Also, the 3 dot tattoo seems to not be a very credible clue.

** I think Jane must've realized this when he saw 3 of them had it and 2 did not. maybe he told Bertram, Smith and MacCalister to go over to the other side because he realized that it was either Haffner or Stiles who now had to be Red John!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

In
the episode, Devil’s Cherry, Charlotte (Jane’s daughter) shows up and we see
part of the team meet her as well when Jane and Charlotte are talking. We as
viewers see this as part of Jane’s hallucination from ingesting the Belladonna
which is highly probable.

 It could also be interpreted as Jane is still in the
mental institution, because Lisbon seems to know who Charlotte is and then when
Jane is surprised at this, they look at Jane and say to Charlotte, Here he goes
again. It could make us wonder if Lisbon and the team are actually doctors in
his hospital and he’s hallucinating that they are members of the CBI with him
hunting Red John.

Also, during the episode, we see Patrick lying
on a hospital bed talking with Charlotte. The part where Charlotte asks Patrick
if anyone knows who he really is and then he says, Lisbon. Part of the time he
was chained down in the bed (& dressed as if in a mental hospital) and part
of the time he isn’t. It made me wonder if The Mentalist has been Jane in the
mental hospital the entire 1-6 years of the show and Charlotte is actually
alive and visiting him in the mental hospital. Could reality be that he’s been in
there the whole time? I hope not. That’s probably a stretch, but it did make me
wonder.
  
If that’s not it, then
maybe his subconscious or the belladonna was talking to him in Charlotte’s form
to get him to realize how important Lisbon really is in his life and not just
as someone to help him catch Red John.  (We don’t really know for sure because of how
the writers wrote this, but it does get us thinking all sorts of things doesn’t
it?)



I don’t see
a lot of drug references with Haffner, but maybe that is because he is the drug
kingpin! The smarter drug dealers don’t use up their own merchandise. But some
do use their own drugs and perhaps Red John became involved with drugs as a way
to “escape” a troubled upbringing.
Cults like Visualize who are often experts at finding prey who have mother issues and father issues with father figures that young adults are in need of, (ex: Bret for Ray) could take advantage of that and use it
for their personal gain. Then that person could seem in control on the outside,
but inside and in secret they can really be a serial killer. The way the clues
led me personally, made me think 100% that  Ray Haffner is Red John

 (But really, any intriguing,
reasonable, logical storyline Heller wrote with clues that led to the correct
suspect would be satisfying. It’s not so much about WHO Red John turns out to
be, it’s more of HOW did Heller & Co. write the clues and did the clues tie
into the storylines that were written and explain and lead to a satisfying and
believable reveal?)


 Which for many of us, hasn’t happened yet.
& for me that hasn’t happened unless Haffner ends up being Red John).

Of course,
this is just my opinion & I’m not pushing it on anyone. But for me, the
clues led to Ray for the reasons stated in my previous posts, as well as:



Considering
Haffner’s background in black ops & surveillance, his age, body type,
handsome face and charming personality, his ties to Visualize, CBI, FBI, most
likely Elliston farm, his competitiveness with Jane, his interest in Lisbon,
injecting himself into cases he has no real business being a part of, getting
funding for his private practice from Brett Stiles/Visualize, how he takes over
Lisbon’s position in CBI and asks Cho who is smarter (asked as a device to see
what the team thinks regarding Jane and how strong their loyalties are to him,
to find out what Jane knows about Red John.)

Faking the fear of the spider,
playing down his intelligence sometimes to fool people into thinking he’s not
as smart as he is when he is very clearly a highly intelligent person as part of
a team or a leader in the FBI, CBI, Black ops, his own business, etc…


Haffner has a
narcissistic and volatile emotional makeup, he fakes concern and is really
furthering his own agenda and trying to gain information he needs (going to
Lisbon’s hospital room). When he said he was headed down a bad path before
joining Visualize, he could be a sociopath hiding in plain sight and I still
feel he is Red John.

These are
just some things I thought about that I compiled in my spare time. (In other
words, when I had time between classes and when The Mentalist went on leave.) Thanks for reading! 

Hope Sunday’s show is a good one for all our sakes! :-D

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Just something interesting to further back up the notion that the final word about Red John is not spoken yet:

Official twitter of Reed Diamond:

https://twitter.com/reeddiamond/status/439264991590350848

@reeddiamond Did you ever think you'd be Red John or did you think it was someone else?

@kentjohnson26: @reeddiamond Did you ever think you'd be Red John or did you think it was someone else?”
How do you know I'm not?"


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on