Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Lorelei Martins

Lorelei Martins
Suspected in 44 theories

THE THEORIES

She was planning to take it to the next level with Patrick Jane.

They had planned an evening of a nice candlelight dinner and rented an X-rated movie. When the movie was done they had passionate sex on the kitchen table. Patrick put on the condom and they went about things. When all was said and done...they couldn't find the condom...

Lorelei then became pregnant with Patrick's love child. Patrick however wouldn't leave his wife so Lorelei took matter in to her own hands to eliminate his family to have Patrick all to herself. 



Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I totally just ran into this image on Pinterest and I can't find it's origin.  Can someone confirm that it's from an old episode and not another spoiler like the tattoo from last week.  Maybe I'm just out of it but it suddenly seemed plausible that Jane faked Lorelei's death and Lisbon's getting mad at him for lying.  Please someone confirm it's an old picture because this is not a twist I wanted to see coming.

http://media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/originals/7a/96/c9/7a96c90e826e5ed6091b22524a8bb5a4.jpg

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

To start off, I'm not saying she is red john, but it made me pick someone.

It's just about the tyger tyger and red john thing. Remember the FBI hiding her away from patrick jayne? The group is linked to red john somehow, maybe he used to be one of them, or has info on them, but there is a reason why that they don't want jayne to find red john, atleast before they do.
They (the tyger club) are clearly scared what jayne might find out, and jayne is going to need a continued motivation for the series, so somehow they are involved in a bad way. I don't beleive they are working together, or they belong to red john. red john got insulted by jayne, a collective wouldnt have such volatile emotions, theyd have an agenda and wouldnt risk it just to prove a point, like RJ did. 

So the question is how RJ and the tyger club are linked. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

This man, with his usual red ties, was born to be Red John:

http://s22.postimg.org/bsgb6t5s1/Red_Tiger_Tie.jpg

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The  more I watch, the more I suspect Lorelei.  She seems to be at the center of everything and remember, she is the one who supplied Jane with the list in the first place.  How convenient.  She has an ongoing vendetta--the murder of her sister, and showed up out of the blue in Las Vegas and inserted herself in Jane's life.  Then she shows up in the car with the Red John "dummy" and the poor victim for the shootout in Henderson.  This is all too convenient.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

"How could RJ have known all the people on the list?", asks Lisbon. It's a trick, Jane replies. And Jane is right and the only way such a trick could work is if Lorelai is actually still alive. RJ is Lorelai - Kirkland is an associate of RJ/Lorelai who was able to use his Homeland Security team to break into Jane's office. Easy enough to dress up a body that looks like Lorelai, considering how ornate RJ kills.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Someone else who thinks that Gale Bertram being Red John is too obvious.
Definitely an accomplice, but not Red John. Why would Bruno Heller make
it so easy for the viewers.
We can speculate a lot of who is Red
John, weather Partridge died or dint die, or if it is the mentalist Bret
Stiles who doesnt fit the description Harker gave, maybe its Bob
Kirkland but on the other hand he wasnt recognized by those who knew Red
John etc. My point is that those seven on the list, any of them could
be Red John. The writers are of course very skillful and therefore gave
them abilities that could point them out as Red John but also deny them.
I think its not a good idea to try to find who Red John is by searching
the clues that has been told. I believe the answer is in the text "he
is mar". This is the one of the clues that has been forgotten or not
talked about. There may be more similar clues but i cant think of them
right now. I also believe that when Red John is revealed, it  will make
perfect sense.

Gale Bertram calling Jane "the wonder boy" is on
big clue, but Bertram doesnt fit the physical description at all. Brett
Stiles and Jane are both mentalist but Stiles doesnt fit the description
at all. I havent even begun with the voice that only suits Partridge.

"he is mar"
mar = ocean in spanish
Written fro the left or right maybe give the text from a different spelling. Maybe reversed?
Maybe the text isnt finished.

Anyway even this doesnt make sense, why would Red John not fully kill his victims...
I
am perfectly happy with waiting and see till episode 8 and I think no
one will have the right to say "I told you so" because of the fact that
every theory could easily be countered.

BTW Lorelei is a beauty. I hope she returns..

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on