Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

I want to say that i realize of something watching every episode again, and i found a person who i think can be RJ, he is dean harken.
I notticed since the first moment he appeared in the show some wear things, the fisrt one, he shook hands with patrick, the second one was he is the only person who calls PJ " patrick" as RJ does not like everybody else who calls him "mr. Jane", dean harken has no photo in his id cdca, i mean if he is the boss in there and someone very important, why he hasn't took that picture.
In one scene he clearly says" i'm gonna call my FBI friends to take care of you" so we noticed he has important friends in there. Also he is in PJ's notebook. And the last one, they didn't like each other since they shook hands, so thats why they didn't become friends.
That's my theory, sorry about my english but i really want to submit my opinion, hope you like it

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I really have no idea who it is.  I am just finishing re-watching every episode for the third time.  Every time I feel like I have an idea, there are several reasons to eliminate that suspect.  The show seems to really like the term "red herring", and I believe that any "obvious" suspect is just that ("a red herring").  My best guess is that the person works within the cbi and is close to Jane.  Not only because it makes sense with the story, but will be good for ratings.  
I also think that Red John is probably the actual leader of Visualize and Brett Stiles is just the poster boy.
 I have a feeling that they may have changed the identity of Red John as the series progressed.  A show never knows how long it will be on the air, so I doubt that the first season gave away too many obvious clues.  I think that the 4th and 5th season probably gives us the most info.  That being said though, I do think that the clues in s4 / s5 (if accurate) will hold true to events that occurred during the beginning of the show.  I think that the shaking hands quote is not literal and is a Red Herring.  I do think Jane knows Red John, because Red John would find that amusing.
Brett Partridge fits a lot of the molds and clues, but it does not make good writing sense.  I find it hard to believe that they would make a crime scene investigator the killer.  It follows Dexter too closely and doesn't make for creative writing.
Kirkland is too obvious.
Any of the inner circle would be too far of a stretch.
I have considered Ron for quite a while.  I find that he is a good bet.  There is nothing too obvious and a lot of speculation, but the speculation makes sense in several instances.  He is a Waldo character.  Ron, however, has always had a beard and Rossalind never mentions a beard in her description.  The main problem I have with Ron is the fact that he is so awkward.  I think that the actor who plays Ron struggles.  I find it hard to believe that the will cast Ron as Red John because I think he is going to have to do some serious acting in the final season.
Like I said, I am no farther ahead after watching The Mentalist 300+ times.  All I know is that I will be sad when its done.......but I am still dying to know.  Please just don't fade to black like Sopranos. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Robert Kirkland is RJ. Why? First I would like to say why Patrick isn't. Simply, because Lorelei said "the moment you two shook hands". She knew both of them and she knew he is someone else.
For the very same reason, it has to be someone who shook his hand with Jane.
Kirkland did it. Kirkland also was the one who said "thank you" on the end of the episode showed us Patrick's beggining in the CBI.
And after the very last episode: Kirkland is a murderer, a one who have done this before and murdered because he was afraid to be identified. As who? As Red John, of course!
How is Brett Styles getting into the picture? I would speculate he might even be related to Kirkland. His father, maybe. This is the reason why he knew about what RJ is about to do but didn't handed him to CBI.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #2118 • By lizbunzhot
Show this theory

1. PJ is RJ or has an ego that wants to merge with him. RJ killed PJ family to lead him into despair seeking revenge which will bring out his dark side making it easier to merge.
2. RJ has followers that protect him and leave PJ hints that he's RJ. Bp saving Jane and saying the tiger tiger poem is one example. Also the man at the RJ hideout watching on the monitor was there to protect pj/RJ to ensure he's safe. PJ was in his RJ mode and checked the door to make sure it was locked so he wouldn't get caught. The guy at the blind ladies house was an enforcer ensuring the she called the CBI about the morgue attendant that way they would see RJ killed while they were with PJ and wouldn't blow his cover. She also acted as if she didn't know PJ to ensure this as well.
3. PJ/RJ "killed" KF because she talked to his wife and he didn't want it getting out he killed his family. This would explain why his wife wasn't in the hallucination after PJ drunk the tea because she would know he killed her but his daughter was asleep so she was clueless thus safe in PJ's subconscious.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #2112 • By Zander
Show this theory

Imagine that we see patrick wake up one day in the mental institution that we are told he was in for a year after his wife and child were murdered, and it was all in his mind. he was just some whack job that they found, he had no name and they called him john doe. the walls in his room were painted red, therefore his subcontious made up the name red john in his dream. there never was a red john, he never had a wife and kids, he was just a loony.

all be it, extremely unlikely but imagine? 

i think most fans would be so annoyed, i would be... would you?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #2111 • By ROJO_JUAN13
Show this theory

Just thought about the timeline at the farm. It was 25 years ago and grace seems to be in her early 30's of at least the actress is about 30. The guy at the farm mentioned a kid and Jane thought he meant 20 -25 but what if the kid was actually 5-6. The two guys could've tried to rape her or her sister so she and someone there killed them. Plus it would fit that RJ had accomplices and helpers early in his/her career which would possibly mean gvp needed it where she was young and weaker. Her sister might have been killed by those two guys or raped then killed herself later in life due to trauma.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

It's hard to speculate at this point but it's definitely not going to be one of the usual suspects and it's easy to rule out most of them already:

- All the dead people can be ruled out immediately.
- Hightower is definitely not RJ, RJ would not run away or be framed anyhow...
- Dr. Steiner is in prison. RJ is not.
- Brenda Shettrick - definitely not, because Red John would never play Volker's informant or anything...
- Rosalind Harker is definitely not RJ because she is convincingly blind. She might be more involved in RJ's business but she is not RJ.
- you can also exclude anyone who is too young to be Red John. Van Pelt, Cho and Rigsby were too young in 1988 when Red John was already somehow connected to Visualize and spent time on that firm. That would probably also exclude Ardilles.
- Minelli is a good guy. LaRoche is definitely not him. Mashburn is fun but he is not nearly sneaky enough to pull it off. Besides, he's too much of a celebrity.

The only couple of people that COULD in fact be Red John from the bunch we've already seen quite a few times are:
- Brett Partridge - he is suspicious  but in my opinion too much of a wuss. I think he likes crimescenes and obscenities but I don't think he could be it.
- Gale Bertram - I found his collaboration with Mr. Homeland Security a bit suspicious, plus I think he was once recited a poem by William Blake to CBI people.
- Bret Stiles - stiles could hypothetically be Red John but it's unlikely.

- Oh and I don't think that's necessary to mention but Jane is not Red John. I mean even if his "search" for RJ was an attempt to hide in plain sight and stuff, his quest to find Red John would be taking it a little too far...
-

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on