Who is Red John?

Theories of turnlach (4)

Come on guys, how can Bertram be Red John?? If someone is bald, he doesn't have short straight hair. And he doesn't have a soft voice, it's the opposite. If Bruno Heller chooses him, he has a lot of explaining to do because it all doesn't make sense at the moment.

In fact, the only person who has a gentle voice and short straight hair is Haffner. I know people here come up with complicated theories and clues, but sometimes we just have to look at simple facts.

But I'm starting to think like hundreds of others here, that Red John is not someone from the list.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

So disappointing that they wrote "Gail" Bertram wrong at the beginning of last week's show..It's laughable! This is a huge show and nobody notices it?? How ridiculous!
Honestly, us fans care more about it all than the people who make it..

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hi guys!
There's something I don't understand..If Red John is really one of the seven, how come he is not doing anything and just lets Patrick closing in on him?
The real Red John that we know from the start wouldn't let this happen.
In the past he always killed everyone that was a risk to him, who could identify him. And he just sits around knowing that Patrick is down to 5 suspects and he is one of them?? It's just weird..

I know he is kind of fond of Patrick but surely he would kill him if he feels PJ is getting too close?? Obviously his own life is much more important to him than Patrick's life? 
I'm really starting to think RJ is NOT on the list and he is laughing about it all..

I only chose the sheriff because I would probably want him out of the 5 the most..

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #3983 • By turnlach
Show this theory

I believe its Minelli because of several things.
The first one that jumped out at me was in the flashback episode to Jane joining the CBI.  Minelli seemed very keen to have Jane on board.  And that phone conversation he had with Agent Shultz, where she said it would be good to have a friend in the FBI. Red John has said himself he has a friend in the FBI so that may be it.
The other thing is his age.  RJ has to be older than Jane given the time the murders started and when it was said he was the friend of Dumar's father. Minelli looks to be right around the right age.
RJ has found it very easy to access CBI network servers.  As the boss and former boss, Minelli could very well still have access to do things like upload the vido of Agent Darcy.
Lastly is the easy way that he left CBI. This has left him plenty of time to do the things RJ does, whether that be murders or turning new followers.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on