NOT A THEORY, A QUESTION
If Jane thinks that Red John is one of his suspects, and that he has 3 dots on his shoulder, what made him think that it is bertram or smith??? why not mcallister who got killed?? soo many questions i hope episode Red John answers them all... I think we are about to witness a big twist...
now few hours before the episode what do you think about this? http://www.whoisredjohn.com/See-a-theory-Red-John/10589#comments
http://www.whoisredjohn.com/See-a-theory-Red-John/10589#comments
*SPOILER ALERT*
the red john episode is about the past and explaining few things that we didnt know, thats why bob kirklad and partrige and... are included in this episode
Wtf guys you say that only partrige and bertram are on imdb list i just viewed the cast list so either im blind or you are dumb but
I CANT SEE neiter patrick jane, or lisbon or anyone else from the team on the list. so how can you even say that one of partrige and bertram is red john the description clearly says that Jane meets RJ face to face, so Baker must be in the episode.
Or else i have a theory that might be possible the Jane RJ contact shown in episode 8 will be from their past, maybe when they met the first time as still teenagers or something like that, Jane will be dreaming or just thinking about the past and the whole episode will be shown like that. we will know who is rj at the end of 8 and jane will know who is rj by the and of 8 but the actual contact in the present time wont exist not yet in episode 8.
my theroy, sorry for bad english hope you understood it. byebye
My theory will probably not be among the most popular theories here but here is how I see the things.
We all are aware that only people from the list of 7 were able to be on the right places in the right time for killings that Red John committed.
We are also aware that Heller already stated that "we can trust the list," but also that we would be disappointed when we find out who Red John is. We also heard that after some time in season 6, it will no longer be about who Red John is, but about catching him.
Therefore, I can state my theory here:
Red John doesn't exist as a single person. There might be a leader of the Tiger,tiger organization, but that's all what his job is. All of the Tiger, tiger members are actually Red Johns for themselves. The organization kills everyone who comes in their way somehow, and acts under the alias of Red John. It's simple, they have many regions covered, they act together, and share their assignments.
Sheriff Thomas McAllister is, for example, Red John for Napa county, Gale Bertram's job is to keep Patrick Jane in his sight, and under his control. We've seen Reede Smith in action in the last episode. Brett Partridge's job was removing the existence of eventual evidence that was left on crime scene. Bret Stiles' job... probably the biggest one, he's most probably the brain behind this whole organization. Ray Haffner... well, you can call him Roy Tagliaferro if you preffer.
The thing is that the list is probably too small for everyone that is involved.
Also, remember the "He is man" clue from Mexico, in an opening season. Thinking about it now, "he is many" would fit perfectly.
I've kept it short and brief, so I probably left some things unexplained.
I was thinking about who Red John is for a while now. I didnt believe it was Jane, I always suspected Cho i dont know why but to me he looks identicly like the Red John's smiley face, until today i watched the Red John's rules episode.
I guess many of you havent noticed what the song in the end of the episode is about. :) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Cxhl8AwOf0
Something's got a hold of my heart!!!!!!
Keeping my soul and senses apart!!!!!!
Something`s gotten into my life
Cutting its way through my dreams like a knife
Turning me up, turning me down
Making me smile and making me frown
I am still not sure but to me more times i listen to that more sure i am that it is Jane, besides, Jane is the woman name for John.