Who is Red John

I just finished the episode. It was decent. I thought it would be better, but I don't see a need to be down on it. I do wish that the McAllister reveal would have been done better (we discovered he was alive through the promo). That's sloppy.
The pigeon thing was super dumb, but thats about the level this show has usually been at. It's not their fault I had higher expectations.

I'm fine with McAllister being RJ. I was surprised that Xander Berkley was not very good in the role. He was fine as McAllister but not quite up to being RJ. It seems he has one character he can do and not much range. Overall though, the episode was OK. They left some room to answer some questions over the next few episodes.

Oh one thing I missed...people had been telling me for weeks on this sight that Brett Partridge was dressed as a woman feeding pigeons. Even though she didn't look anything like him, people assured me it was him. Did anyone notice how they explained that in this episode? I must have missed it :)

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

So I just saw the episode here in Nicaragua. Its definitely a different episode. SPOILER:
Summer and Cho both turn into pigeons and fly to Dubai, also Bret Stiles is the secret father of every character on the list of 7. I can confirm this because I am in canada and I also saw the episode. And me to, I am in Kenya and saw it on Amazon Prime Kenya, and we are all posting from the same account. I hope this clears everything up. Any questions?

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

So those who have been fooled by the fake episode are still posting the same lame, "get over it it's real," posts. SO if you are so sure of yourself (and no full of doubt waiting for us to convince you otherwise), why are you still on this site? It is because you are not as confident about your remarks as you want us to think. Other wise you wouldn't be coming back to this site, hoping the page loads, and hoping we've given you a new nugget to give you hope.

The episode is a fake. If you disagree and you are not as pathetic as I now beleive you to be, then I would expect to not see you on a site that asks the question that you claim you already know the answer to. Fair enough?

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

First, if you wan't to believe the leaked episode (Yes it is a fake) is real, by all means go ahead..just make sure you watch the episode tonight so you can laugh at how gullible you were.

Two, if you think the Mentalist production team has not been at this site passively, you are further fooling yourself.

Three, When you watch tonight, you will see that RJ is neither Bertam or McAllister, and no there will not be a scene where PJ is sleeping at the former CBI office loft.

Now go ahead and tell me how the fake episode is on itunes thus proving it's "real."

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

To those who really can't tell that the leaked episode was a fake, let me help you out.
1. You will see a different episode tomorrow
2. McAllister will not be revealed as RJ in tomorrows episode
3. When you see Jane kill RJ in the park, it will be one of the 7 that we thought was dead, but again, that person will not be McAllister.

Hope this calms you down a little

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

OK this is getting ridiculous. If you watched that brilliant prank that I saw and you think it is the real episode, I am truly stunned at your intelligence.

McAllister is RJ and grew up as LaROche's brother?
VanPelt banging her head against the car because Rigsby is paying more attention to Hightower?
Really?? If you can't tell this is fake, you need some self examination.
And oh by the way did you notice the gun was plastic....

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

OK a new obvious clue that we should all say, "why didn't we pick up this clue sooner."

post this reluctantly. Trust me, I am so sure Bertram is not RJ (RJ would never plan ahead to have fake passports since he wouldnt beleive hed ever need to escape or be caught), butt.... A clue in ep 7 when Lisbon and Jane here that Bertram's aunt has a place at "Citrus Heights"

Sadly this ties in well with the early (I believe it was a reading Jane did on RJ) comments about living with a family member with a citrus tree in the yard... to eerie to no be a clue..
Weird..

Don't kill the messenger. I still do not believe Bertam is RJ..no way

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

Theories of mikefit (43)