Who is Red John?

Theories of Truufinator (2)

Ok.  Here's another theory of mine.  This time instead of Minelli I wanna go with Haffner but only in a halfway sense.  When Red John first started out he had a partner named Orville Tanner.  Who's to say Red John doesn't always keep a partner around during his killings?  When Red John was talking to Patrick he had both hands free.  Of course you could say he was holding the phone with his shoulder/ear or bluetooth but for the sake of this theory I'm going to say there were two guys there.  One is the voice/mind of Red John and the other does his dirty work/killing.  Haffner does the dirty work since his voice sounds nothing like him and.......Sean Barlow or Virgil Minelli is the voice/mind/brains.  Someone else posted this really cool vid on youtube about Haffner.  Watch it.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EECBjnasoEk&list=WLLSLLkh0wPJZ10LsEC2rwJHk3shVxfvVi

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Personally, I don't think it is anyone on the list. The clue I think in episode one at the end wasn't what anyone did but rather the location/setting of what took place.  Watch http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p43ysF_NFI8 Patrick and Minelli talk about a murder victim who was in an "abandoned house" (just like where Partridge was killed) Red John could have been trying to jog Patrick's brain about that particular conversation in season 6. The voices of Minelli and Bosco sound like they could be Red John with a tad bit of inflection on their part. Comparing body type and hair to the Red John Promo vid for the next episode I'd say it's more like Minelli. Also, Minelli was there from the beginning.  The pigeons....well, could mean "message" as in messenger pigeon.  This was the message Minelli was trying to send to Patrick.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on