I'm curious to see who actually still thinks Red John is one of the 5.
Up until now I was quite certain Bruno Heller wouldn't lie to us about it but after the last episode I can't see any of them as Red John..None of them seem fascinating or brilliant like this 'great' serial killer who has been killing for so many years..Even Bret Stiles is dying and he seemed quite insane in this episode. (not in a good way)
GREEN: Red John is NOT one of the 5.
RED : Red John is one of the 5.
Lol, when Lisbon said: "..or at least give us a PLAUSIBLE motive" my first thought was this website.:D We need to get a life.:)
I'm still accusing the sheriff but I really don't know anymore..
There was something in that moment when he reached out to help Patrick on the roof and they showed their hands together..It was very mysterious. Like the murderer who killed his family, is reaching out to him, to help him and in a way, play with him..
I only got that feeling from the sheriff so far..:)
I actually don't like coming to this website anymore because of the people who post their theories about Patrick Jane being Red John.
When I read these silly posts it's like a comedy site, a Mentalist parody!!
STOP it people, Patrick Jane is NOT Red John!! There are hundreds of reasons why he can't be!!
You are not paying any attention to the program!! So tiring, just stop it already!
My dear fellow Partridge fans!
The time has come to accept that Partridge is dead and not coming back! I'm very sad to say this because I was/am his biggest fan..I'm not even very excited about who Red John is anymore..
If you don't believe me, ask Jack Plotnick on facebook. He is a very, very nice guy and he writes back to his fans. (obviously don't be a crazy stalker, be polite).
When he writes back to you, you will have absolutely no doubt in your mind that he is done with the show.:( (he doesn't even have to answer this question to fans but he does. He is lovely).
He is not Red John. There's no point speculating about it anymore.
RIP Partridge.
I think it's between Haffner and McAllister.
I'm going with the sheriff, at least there is some mystery about him which makes him much more intriguing than Haffner who doesn't seem to have much of a personality..
Which one would you rather see as Red John? GREEN - Haffner
RED - Sheriff
Does anybody else get the feeling that when Red John said tyger, tyger in the season 2 finale, Bruno Heller had not come up with this whole tiger, tiger organization idea yet?
It feels like he's just added this whole other storyline recently..I'm a bit disheartened by all of this, he's always said he knew exactly what was going to happen from the beginning but it really doesn't look like it at the moment.
I don't know who to accuse any more, I just chose Brett Partridge because every other outcome will seem a bit boring to me..It could be Haffner though.
Before you all kill me, I meant to theories about Patrick Jane being Red John are painful to read, not the other theories!!! OK? :D