Who is Red John?

Theories of Jerry (2)

There is no doubt this is the true and final ending.

What a crock of shit.

In an interview with TV Guide, they specifically mentioned that Bruno Heller "chose" McAllister to be Red John about a year ago!!! - Meaning Heller had NO PLAN about who Red John was supposed to be from the very beginning.  That.  Is.  UNFORGIVABLE.  He never had a plan, never had a story.  It's why NONE of our questions will ever be answered ("He is Mar") - THERE WERE NEVER ANY ANSWERS!!!  He was making it up as he went along.

I will never watch this show again.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I think Heller is messing this up big time. It's becoming as confusing and inconsistent as LOST.

First of all, we should have discovered Red John's identity at the end of last season, not 1/3 of the way through season 6. It reeks of "Whoops, I've left them guessing for too long... Better give it up while they're still watching!"

Secondly, to introduce this whole new Tyger Tyger conspiracy group THIS LATE IN THE GAME is desperate and insulting. Don't add more layers NOW, Bruno - just tie up the loose ends that have laid out for us over 5 years!

I think he's turning Red John into a red herring so he can keep his show going. I'm predicting a cop-out reveal, where RJ died months ago and now others are carrying on his work or some nonsense like that. Or that RJ was never one guy, but a group of people blah blah blah, as if there are that many people in the word who all want to become serial killers and join a serial killer group. Crikey.

This whole Kirkland thing for me was the last straw. He was hunting RJ the whole time? Please. Then why didn't he ask Lennon for RJ's identity before he killed him? So dumb. Oh, wait! It was his twin! Now he has a freaking TWIN??? Come on! That is all.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on