Who is Red John

To add to what I posted earlier...

What do you think of this idea?

Maybe Red John could have been some sort of cult. A sort of guru- disciple thing- with only one disciple at a time.

So the red barn could have been done by the 'previous' Red John. Jane's family would be killed by 'current' Red John. And at the end when Jane is killing Red John- the serial killer tells him in a mocking way- 'but I am already succeeded' or 'I have already been succeeded'...and so Jane is faced with a dilemma- should he kill the guy or should he keep him alive to find out the identity of the 'new' Red John?

Sorry about my english.

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

Apologies for bad english in advance

Heller could have said-'He is mar' is a blind clue left by Red J himself. The 7 suspects might have been revealed by Jane to someone during a psychotic break. Lorelei maybe- all the time he spent with her? Would be interesting if Jane actually had a psychotic break at the end of 4- when he thought he was faking it. Blake A was needed maybe cos it does seem logical that Red J would need people to collect all the info he required. But mcallister could have been shown as some sort of a puppet master- rather than an actual member

Showdown in red J ep should have been structured differently. maybe red J captured Jane and made him listen to all his plans?

Red J should not have been in an official position (sheriff or bertram's role). Official work involves a lot of paperwork- and somehow I do not see Red J doing any such work. Showman- paralleling Jane (Stiles) suits him better

The lead characters should have continued in their platonic way forever.

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

Theories of EB8 (2)