Who is Red John?

Theories of Duane (4)

This HappyCool guy that reviewed the episode as a media member said on his youtube page that we shouldn't believe all the talk about the leaked episode.  He said we better watch Sunday.  So we still have hope it is a fake it seems.........

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Just on the chance that the leaked episode is a fake, no matter who Red John turns out to really be, we will all owe Heller TONS of praise.  It could be one of the best swerves in TV history.  The reveal to the casual fan will be as exciting as it was always going to be, and the reveal to us hardcore fans who have seen the leaked episode will have us going crazy.  This site will be packed with comments and the buzz after Sunday will be huge.


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

If Red John is definitely on the list, I just don't buy any of them as him except for Robert Kirkland.  Somehow, it will come out that his brother was the one shot by Reede Smith.  He is the only one I can see PJ confronting where I'm thinking "yes he is that smart, that evil, and that manipulative."

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

OK, it should be obvious now why Kirkland was asking the "fake" suspects if they recognized him.  If one of them was actually red john, they would certainly recognize him since they killed his twin.  So we can now eliminate Partridge and Kirkland.  We can eliminate Reede Smith, Sheriff McAlester, and Bertram.  They are part of this new story line about an inside group that will be an ongoing part of the plot after red john is revealed.  

That leaves just Ray Haffner and Bret Stiles.  Haffner is joining the CBI to help with some kind of investigation on next week's episode.  He is the only one that fits the profile to be red john, unless red john turns out to be someone not on the list of 7.

Also, I've always thought the "he is mar" was going to be "he is married to......", but I just never could put the pieces together.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on