Now the list is down to three. Everyone knows that RJ is now a tyger tyger member. But who could Red John be? I guess many of us would believe it to be either Bertram or Mcallister. Very few would think Smith to be Red John. Why, because there is little or no proof to say Smith is Red John. All the clues from Sophie miller and Rosalind Harker prove Smith is not RJ, except for one. Smith has fear of heights. Now everyone would be really disappointed if Smith was RJ. He does not look like one. If there were no clues by Harker or Rosalind, then I would have thought he might be RJ. RJ could be either Mcallister or Bertram. But one question remains, did anyone know about who Red John was in the tyger tyger community. I believe it was Smith who really killed that woman. Let us wait and see who RJ would be. If it is Smith, then I would have to say that all of Heller's clues were wrong and he is nothing more than a sloppy writer.