Who is Red John?

Theory #8394 • by abdullahinoman

Suspect

Bret Stiles

Bret Stiles
Suspected in 550 theories

ARGUMENTATION

The other thing that has been bugging me is the fact that we've been taking Rosalind at face value. Whose to say that she A: is really blind and B:doesn't work for RJ?? Since when does RJ have romantic getaways with random women and listen to classical piano?? He's shown us that all of his moves are calculated, yet we're supposed to believe that finding Rosalind was a mistake?? I think that leading Jane to her was his way of starting up the game with Jane, to see if he was clever enough to be a worthy opponent. If this is true, then we can assume any physical description given by Rosalind would be false. This would also explain why Jane never excluded the suspects from the list that didn't match her description, nor ask her to try and identify the remaining suspects. It would also be a shocker but not unrealistic. Tell me what you guys think.

How do you find this theory?
plausible
unlikely
comments powered by Disqus
Follow us on