MAX WINTER is  RED JOHN. RED JOHN SHADOW IN SEASON 1 REPRESENTS HIS  " SPIRIT" , RED JOHN  PLAYING THE ROLE AS THE GRIM REAPER IN SEASON 2 WHEN HE HELPED JANE AND MENTION THE TYGER TYGER  REPRESENTS HIS  "SOUL/MIND" AND IN SEASON 3 HE WAS  PRESENTED IN  " BODY/FLESH"  FOR THE 1ST TIME IN THE PICTURE . SO PUT IT TOGETHER ( SPIRIT,SOUL and BODY): THIS IS THE MANNER IN WHICH  GOD MADE MAN , REMEMBER THE CLUE " HE IS MAN"  AND THE POEM TYGER TYGER SPEAKS  OF GOD DIVINITY IN THE CREATION OF THE TYGER AND WHICH ALSO GOES TOGETHER WITH A NEXT POEM THE LAMB . THEY CANT DO WITH OUT EACH OTHER, THERE CO-EXSISTANCE IS WHAT KEEPS THE BALANCE IN LIFE. HENCE  JANE THE "LAMB'' AND  RED JOHN THE "TYGER" THEY NEED EACH OTHER TO KEEP BALANCE AND ORDER IN THE LIFE CYCLE. SO THE CLUE TO WHO RED JOHN IS ? WELL ITS UP TO YOU BUT HIS 1ST APPEARENCE WAS SOMEWHERE IN SEASON THERE. MY BEST BET AN I HAVE MY FINDINS FOR SAYING SO IS THAT  'RJ' IS EITHER  WALTER MASHBURN OR  MAX WINTER , ONE OUT OF THOSE TWO. WATCH AN U WILL SEE.