Who is Red John?

Theory #7565 • by Jenn Guy

Suspect

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

ARGUMENTATION

I think Heller had this all planned out perfectly. All red herrings are so perfectly thrown to you, you just have to bite. But I didn't!

Look. You have to admit Heller is a step ahead of us, for a reason. His aim was to suspect Haffner at this point, of course.

Everyone is so concentrated on the Sophie Miller's tape. And yes, this was a huge trap. This acrophobia acarophobia thing. That's the trap I'm talking about. Jane explained Lisbon that's a fear of heights and we clever guys figured out, it's actually a fear of bugs and now when we saw Haffner got scared of a little spider, we're all smart, cause we think we solved the case.

No we didn't. Sophie Miller wasn't sure about Jay Roth's phobia. This is Heller leading us into thinking Sophie got the phobia right, when clearly she put her options open and wasn't sure. And we yet blindly believe she is some mastermind who can see everything straight away.

If we can indeed trust RJ is on this list, I still think it's McAllister, cause he is the smartest of all the suspects.

How do you find this theory?
plausible
unlikely
comments powered by Disqus
Follow us on