In my opinion Virgil Minelli is red John. I've rewatched most of the scenes with him in and the looks he gives Jane and the subtle hints he drops. He also has short hair, around or under 6ft, the only doubt I have is his voice unless he uses a voice modifier. He also employed Jane.
I have a feeling rosalind harker is more involved than she lets on also.
How do you find this theory?
plausible
unlikely