Who is Red John?

Theory #4513 • by ILovePJ

Suspect

Unrevealed suspect

Unrevealed suspect
Suspected in 1k+ theories

ARGUMENTATION

Some have theorized on the site that Partridge must be a goner b/c he is one of only two actors to appear in Epi 1, one of whom dies, but BP isn't listed as a cast member for the first episode. The RJ suspects appearing in Desert Rose are McCallister, Bertram and Smith. My hope is Reede doesn't survive. Bertram as a suspect adds so much tension to the season b/c he's the boss so he cannot be a victim so early and I don't want it to be McCallister b/c I want him to be RJ. Xander Berkeley would kick it, and I love the idea of Rock, Paper, Scissors as "the handshake". Seriously clever.

If not McCallister, then...here's another thought, but it's out there. Building on the theories that "he is many"...what if RJ is more than one person and always in law enforcement. Was Minelli the original RJ? Then, he "retired" and feeling to much pressure from PJ, he passed the torch to Bertram. Both are fisherman, a clue from the RJ disciple Kirkland killed. Kinda out there? Probably, but I always felt Minelli was RJ, and do we really need to "trust the list"? Heller is a television producer, after all, a seriously untrustworthy breed. :)

Not sure, but one thing I feel confident about is Kirkland is a victim, not perpetrator. He's on his own crusade which is why he keeps watch on Patrick.

How do you find this theory?
plausible
unlikely
comments powered by Disqus
Follow us on