Who is Red John?

Theory #3270 • by YELLOWumbrella

Suspect

Walter Mashburn

Walter Mashburn
Suspected in 325 theories

ARGUMENTATION

last night i saw the season finale of how i met your mother...and we finally saw the mother?after so many seasons.i was really excited right before the reveal ...but right after we saw her face ...i had mixed feelings and the first thought in my head was...is this how i'm going to feel when they revealed red john?excited?dissapointed?is it going to be worth the wait?is it going to be like " monk " all over again?god help us all ..and for the love of god don't let it be a judge and then have patrick revealed that her daughter is not dead after all...or i'm going to throw my tv out the window...AGAIN.I guess is no secret that we're all going to be dissaponted and we're pobably going to care more about patrick and teresa's relationship the the actual reveal of red john....just like today that i'm starting to care more about ted's and robin's relantionship than the actual mother........there better be some exciting twists and turns next season in the mentalist...one last thing...if you are one of those people that think that brett partridge is red john..you are in for a rude awakening.think about it...at the beginning of the series we had like what 10 or 15 suspects..almost all the suspects have 3 or 4 things that made a lot of people think they were red john..whether it was the name,anagram,poetry...they all had something especially one guy brett partridge..since episode one he's been the number one suspect...there's no doubt he is going to be there when rj is reveal...BUT..if brett partridge is reveal to be red john...where's the shock value? he's been the number one suspect since the beginning....the show has been set up to make it look like anybody could be rj....and to look that brett partridge is rj...only to be revealed that rj is somebody else and you'll say..WTF!....IT HAS TO BE the least person to be suspected to be rj....somebody like reede smith or sheriff mcalister..if brett p....is revealed to be rj...America and the whole world will say...of course i knew it from the beginning...it makes perfect sense...but where's the fun in that...NO SHOCKING VALUE.

How do you find this theory?
plausible
unlikely
comments powered by Disqus
Follow us on