Who is Red John?

Theory #17059 • by Stoopkid

Suspect

Grace Van Pelt

Grace Van Pelt
Suspected in 303 theories

ARGUMENTATION

Lorelie martins is still alive!! Two points:

1: hard evidence - lorelie was shot in her left arm below her shoulder . She had a bandage on it when we last saw her alive. Then she left to go kill red john.
In the dvd she made she still had the bandage on her arm.
When we see her dead body however, her arm is uncovered and has not one little scratch on it !

2: metaphorical evidence - before the camera goes on her dead body you can see a poster of a "4 legged woman" and it says in big bold letters "ALIVE" !
Why would a poster of a 4 legged woman say alive ?
I believe the body was lorelie's sister who red john could of had on ice all these years.
He has done that before .

I make these points because the key to red john was that dvd. Something was very off about lorelies speech.
Making jane take out his list of 7 after she commended him from narrowing a list of thousands to a few names.
It seemed like the dvd was for Lisbon.

Other points:
Why was bertram told to tell jane the game is over right before Macalister says the same exact thing ?
More importantly , why was the game over ? After all these years red john decides right then at the church the game was over ? Jane was there for bertram? Weird.
Also as i said yesterday, patrick said it wasnt a game, i asked to play?
When did this happen? Janes family was murdered he didn't ask for anything !

How do you find this theory?
plausible
unlikely
comments powered by Disqus
Follow us on