Who is Red John?

Theory #16814 • by RedRedPunkPunk

Suspect

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

ARGUMENTATION

Nothing would please me more than McAllister's not the real
villain. There is however a fact that is very strong evidence for the opposite.
PJ killed again! And to be precise, we should say that he killed two people.

Ok, the audience would gladly tolerate the righteous kill of the beast, that
caused Jane so much suffering and loss. But how many times? Timothy Carter was
murdered for nothing. Yeah, he was evil, he was a criminal and a kidnapper. But
was he Red John? Actually not!

In episode 8 of the last season Jane killed again. This time the real Red John.
Believe it or not, the stupid sheriff is the real one. It's about the silly
voice, it's about the close view of Simon Baker in the very moment of the Red
John's end, when to be fair Baker made another great performance, it's about
the murder of the Red John's associate.

The majority of people have a sense of justice. We all know, that the criminals
deserve to be punished. The writers know that and they can not afford
themselves let the main protagonist kill people just for nothing. Ultimately we
can tolerate the vengeance, but not indiscriminate and unjustified murders.


The whole 8th episode
was not another misdirection, it was just bad written and directed. I just hope
for the rest of the season, that Bruno Heller will give us a strong and
plausible mind twist, that will rock us. A lot. I know he can do it.

At least show us in flashbacks what a sadistic and unscrupulous psychopath
McAllister was.


After all, Patrick Jane got his satisfaction.We just want to get ours!






How do you find this theory?
plausible
unlikely
comments powered by Disqus
Follow us on