Lets make this very simple.
Green: Sherrif Thomas McAllister is Red John. The Red John story is over, and we are left with a lot of loose ends (eventhough some are answered, like Red Johns phobia, tyger tyger burning bright, etc.)
Red: Red for Red John, he is still out there and will blow everyones mind in the finale episode (eventhough Heller said the Red John story is officially over now).
How do you find this theory?
plausible
unlikely