Who is Red John?

Theory #16047 • by Coolos

Suspect

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

ARGUMENTATION

So, how on earth did the sheriff convince T Carter to die for him? He certainly wasn't blake association. 

And... if RJ Macallister planned to kill Jane and Bertram in the same scenario, giving an end noone would ask about, would this mean that the sheriff was willing to stop killing under the RJ identity to bury the case? (maybe he would still do it under another alias).

What I mean by this is that in the end RJ didn't exist to the person who was RJ. McAllister didn't believe in RJ, and he was up to drop the character just to prevent from being caught. The sheriff always took RJ as a façade, and this is the most disappointing conclussion. It doesn't make sense. I was waiting RJ to be someone to at least believe his own delusions. A crazy man.


He played Patrick all along, even dying. Even if he was the one to kill Jane's family, McAllister wasn't RJ cause RJ doesn't exist. He was just a fiction, he makes fun of the voice.

SOOO, big question... If RJ wasn't believing his own shite, how on earth did he get so many followers and surrogates?



So many questions, and so many doubts, and gret pain no to get a decent, rational, logical answer to them. 

How do you find this theory?
plausible
unlikely
comments powered by Disqus
Follow us on