Who is Red John?

Theory #15473 • by LaMente

Suspect

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

ARGUMENTATION

I liked and hated the episode.

I liked it because Jane was right all along. He was "an ugly, tormented little man. A lonely soul. Very sad," as he said on the talk show. RJ tried to play himself up as a god, probably as a way to prove Jane wrong, but once the Blake association was disbanded, he had no one to call on. He was simply a sick little man who had a bunch of "friends," who were only his friends because he manipulated them into helping him. (People joined Blake Association to cover up wrongs. Women helped him because he offered them something - a child, love, acceptance, etc...) He really did have delusions of grandeur. He even thought he was psychic.

I hated it bc it did leave a lot of unanswered questions, but I think we should start doing theories to answer those questions. I have a few below.

How did he make the list?
I think he was really smart, and has followed Jane so he deduced the same list, or he paid Sean Barlow who could be a real psychic. RJ said he was a real psychic to impress Jane one last time, poor fool.

What is "He is mar?"
I think RJ wrote this himself to screw with Jane.

Rosalind Harker's description?
The sherif probably had more hair and less fat then.

Why kill Partridge?
He was a loose end.

Kristina Frye?
Had a friend hypnotize her. I'd like to see more of Sean Barlow, that he was involved. That's a great actor, and it would give us the carny theme we were wanting with RJ.

Visualize?
I think RJ hated visualize. Probably irked him that Bret Stiles was a fake. That's why he killed the 2 Visualize members in the house explosion. He probably knew about the farm and killed everyone.

What do y'all think?

How do you find this theory?
plausible
unlikely
comments powered by Disqus
Follow us on