First of all, I'm really open-minded, I mean, I'm not a hater, I always liked Partridge as Red John but I didn't look blindly to it, I've always checked the other theories and honestly, a lot were plausible.
Now about this last episode... seriously? That was the great Red John appearance?
I'm not complaining about the fact that McAlister was Red John but how he faced Jane..."please don't kill me" like, really?
On my mind Red John would act just like the emperor on the Gladiator's final scene (2000 film). He would say something about Jane's wife and daughter that would make us hate him hard and laugh on his face in a psychotic way and then he goes "you can kill me Patrick, nothing will change, you won't have your wife and child back" (which is true) and then he says "the game is over and I won".
Speaking of which, wtf was that? They just dubbed his voice on this phrase..WHY? So the promo would tease us, seriously this revelation makes no sense to me at all, specially the fact that the great mastermind Red John was so pathetic when facing his nemesis and begging for his life.
What about the pidgeon? How the heck Cordero didn't notice that when cheking for any guns? And why did Patrick had a pidgeon with him if he though Bertram was Red John?
And I'm not sure how a sheriff can be a serial killer like Red John, who controls a freaking secret empire and do his daily sheriff things. I think even Stiles would be a better Red John...

Seriously I am disapointed, not by the fact he was Thomas but because he was so pathetic begging for his life and because he regrets killing Jane's wife and daughter AND he is afraid of death, how come a guy that lives in danger and been hunted the whole life afraid of death? Come on...he seems to be not smart at all and yet he tricket Jane for ten years.
Honestly I think we could have scripted a better episode even Ron had some interesting theories here.
Peace out guys and leave a comment if you will.