Who is Red John?

Theory #12924 • by TheDetective

Suspect

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

ARGUMENTATION

THIS REALIZATION GAVE ME THE CHILLS, IT WILL FOR YOU AS WELL

Stick with me for 30 seconds, I promise you will know Red John

Red John is Thomas McAllister:

What name did Bertrum use to check into Red John's storage unit? Thomas.

What was in the unit? Red Wine. McAllister is from Napa, wine capital of America. 

Rewatch the episode where patrick rounds up the suspects in his house, and makes them reveal their tattoo.

When they are going to reveal, Bertrum looks directly at McAllister, as if waiting for his approval.
Bertrum, the supposedly highest on the totem pole of the Blake association is the only one taking direct orders from Red John...Smith was obviously left in the dark.

When McAllister revealed his tattoo, there was a creepy, chilling music, and Patrick came to a sudden epiphany like realization..He would have shot him then and there if Stiles hadn't urged him to look at the others...

Take a look at the promo found on CBS Website:

The man breaking through the glass, McAllister, is wearing the same clothes as the man, who perfectly fits McAllister's description walking down the church aisle.

HERES THE KICKER: We know McAllister is religious, when he saved Patricks life, he says "Well hell be a lot closer to Jesus now"... We also know he has a phobia of pigeons, which appear in the promo, on a statue of Mary, and fits sophies description perfectly...

This image shows "Red John" poisoning Rebecca in CBI
The man is dressed in 

https://www.google.com/search?q=thomas+mcallister+red+john&safe=off&espv=210&es_sm=91&source=lnms&tb...

hes wearing a sherrifs outfit, someone like mcallister has resources, free time, and could blend in almost anywhere...


ONE LAST THING: 
when the little girl said to patrick "are you giving up yet", it would take someone like a policeman, who can be trusted by small kids, to get a stranger to say that...

I put alot of time into this and dont want it to be buried!!!

IF YOU WANT THIS TO GET TO THE TOP CLICK PLAUSIBLE, IF YOU DONT LIKE IT CLICK UNLIKELY, BUT DONT SCROLL PAST!! 


How do you find this theory?
plausible
unlikely
comments powered by Disqus
Follow us on