So I was looking at the votes on the suspects tab on this website.  Guess who's number one...

Sheriff McAllister!!!

Partridge is a close second, but the ratio of theories to votes is interesting.

Sheriff has 335 theories to his 629 votes.  Partridge has 996 theories to his 584 votes.

It's like the top two suspects ratios are reversals of each other.  Anyone care to guess what the reason for this is?