Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Unrevealed suspect

Unrevealed suspect
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

I don't have a theory and I have stopped trying to figure out.

But what IS CLEAR is that, we have 2 groups amongst us fans:

1. Fans who think/want Brett Partridge as Red John
2. Fans who think/want Ray Haffner as Red John

Now, what would be fun is that writers coming up with something that really really surprises us. Someone else who we know.. That'd be awesome.. and healthy for the show too.
Or maybe not so.. Anyway, I am of the Partridge fan group.

To all my fellow Mentalist fans, I'd say

               KEEP CALM
                      AND
                WAIT FOR
 RED JOHN vs. JANE BATTLE!!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

hello all. i just have one question

In episode ''His red right hand'', 8th episode of 2nd season we found that doctor of 3rd and 4th Red John's victims is dead, dr. Towlen Morning. His body is actually found at the beginning of the episode, naked and placed frozen somewhere outside. It's clear as day he is dead.

Then, in some episode of season 5, actually at the end of episode, we see Jane looking at his book of suspects, and there is a name dr. Towlen Morning and a note: deceased?



My question is why would they do that? Why showing to viewers that doctor, even dead, is still among Jane's evaluation of possible Red John suspect?

Is it something we should consider that in some future episodes, or they are just having a very bad taste and are messing with audience in not right way?



Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

SPOILER ALERT!





PJ say publicly to press a name. Probably one of the leaders of the Tiger. This will make all the police chase that person, leaving his way free to meet RJ at the park. We will see a large gathering. Epic!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I thought the explosion at Jane's was of his own doing, but this promo says otherwise. So, doesn't that perpetuate the Brett Partridge theories? If Red John really bombed that house, wouldn't it be completely irrational of him to actually show up for the meeting and risk blowing himself up? If he were one of the five suspects, wouldn't it have made far more sense to simply wait it out until everyone but him entered the house, and then activate the explosion? Sure, the CBI team would automatically suspect him for being the only one who didn't show up, but still, isn't that better than going in there and probably getting killed by his own device? 

The only way this makes sense for Red John is if he's Brett Partridge. He 'died' so he has a pretty solid alibi. This would also explain why Partridge had to die so soon, he got himself off the radar and was free to carry out his plans. Of course, the faking of a death is a cheap plot point and I didn't want it to happen, but I think Partridge is now the likeliest candidate. This show is not above such a trick.

The only other guy who is on the deceased list is Kirkland, and we know he was actually hunting RJ so he's not an option.

Regarding the promo, when the voice says it's down to the final three suspects, it shows the tattooed ones, but again this conflicts with their reasoning to enter the house.
As for those whose photos are pinned up on the board, I believe they are at large. There would be no point having them up there if they were confirmed dead, as that puts them out of the picture. Also, there is no photo of Partridge there.

Lets hope we learn Red John's identity in the next episode, it's been long overdue.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Simple deductionA. Bruno Heller said that we can trust the list. It has several time been confirmed that Red John is one of the seven suspects.
B. Bret Stiles, who personally knows Red John, was genuinely surprised by Patrick's accusation.

Conclusion: (A+B=) Either Kirkland or Partridge is still alive and is Red John!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

http://www.spoilertv.com/2013/11/the-mentalist-episode-607-great-red_4.html

To people are wondering if Stiles, Haffner and Sheriff McAllister are dead or at large because of thier pictures being on the board, by watching the promo, i think they are dead because Rigsby says "Red John brought in a bomb to kill Jane and the other suspects".  When he says this he points to the pictures of Stiles, Haffner and McAllister, implying that they are dead... ? I think

Watch from 0:08 on the link ^ see what you think.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

does anyone have an idea the guy in  that picture?(see comments)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on