Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Unrevealed suspect

Unrevealed suspect
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

now they deleted the video from youtube. now I had been a staunch 'red herring' guy but now......hmm....i dont think its an easy answer....i am confused now..two cases


1-    There was a leak adn yes it is real

2-    It was a fake meant only for the hardcore junkies and hence not for utube audience.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

 THE EPISODE WAS NOT LEAKED!. IT WAS ON THE CBS PRESS WEBSITE. IT WAS NOT HACKED!. THEY PURPOSELY LEFT THE LINK IN THE FREAKING VIEW SOURCE. IF ANYONE IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THIS, IT IS CBS NOT ANY HACKER! SO jimmy gadd SAID IT WAS HACKED....... RIGHT..... IF YOU ARE COMPUTER ILLITERATE AND CAN'T FREAKING USE A SIMPLE RIGHT CLICK VIEW SOURCE, THEN THAT MAKES YOU ASSUME THE SITE WAS HACKED. FOR A SITE TO BE HACKED, IT MEANS SOMEONE WHO CAN ACTUALLY HACK HAS TO HACK IT, THEN STEAL THE VIDEO. WHICH WAS AND IS NOT THE CASE. CBS HAD IT ON THERE TO EASILY FOR ANYONE TO SEE. LIKE A PUZZLE THAT TAKES 10 SECONDS TO SOLVE. SO STOP BLAMING HACKERS AND STOP SAYING IT WAS LEAKED.. NEITHER OF THAT IS TRUE...... CBS HANDED IT OUT LIKE FREAKING CANDY AND IF THIS IS THE REAL ONE, THEN I AM ANGRY BECAUSE IT IS CBS WHO IS AT FAULT. IF THIS WAS A MISTAKE ON THEIR PART, THEN THEY SHOULD OWN UP TO IT AND STOP BEING LITTLE GIRLS AND BLAMING OTHERS. THEY ARE THE ONES WHO MESSED UP, OR THEY DID IT ON PURPOSE, EITHER WAY ALL FINGERS SHOULD POINT TO CBS!!!!!!!!!! AND NO ONE ELSE! EVERYTIME I GET ON THIS WEBSITE I HEAR ABOUT HACKED AND LEAKED......... SHUT UP ALREADY AND USE COMMON SENSE. PLEASE. PEOPLE SHOULD BE FLOODING CBS WITH QUESTIONS ABOUT WHY THEY ARE LYING TO THE PEOPLE. WHAT SUCH CRAP ON THEIR PARTS. AS OF COURSE UNLESS THEY INTENDED THIS. THEN WHATEVER. BUT IT STILL ALL POINTS SIMPLY BACK TO CBS LETTING PEOPLE SEE THE VIDEO VERY VERY VERY VERY VERY EASILY. NOBODY STOLE IT, NOBODY HACKED THEIR STUPID WEBSITE. AND IF THIS IS THE REAL VIDEO, THEN BLAME CBS FOR CRYING OUT LOUD. AND TELL THEM TO REMAKE THE DAMN THING BECAUSE IT COMPLETELY SUCKED! THEY SHOULD HAVE ENDED IT WITH THE FIRST TIME JANE THOUGHT HE HAD KILLED RED JOHN, THAT WAS A PERFECT FREAKING WAS TO DO IT, BUT NOOOOO, THEY HAD TO DO A BULLSHIT FLOP ON THEIR ASSES AND MAKE THIS SHIT CONTINUE AND RUIN A WHAT COULD HAVE BEEN PERFECT ENDING TO THE RED JOHN STORY A LONG TIME AGO WHEN HE THOUGHT HE KILLED HIM THE FIRST TIME. AND THIS TYGER TYGER SHIT IS SO ANNOYING. SO IS NO TRUE QUESTIONS THE AUDIENCE WANTS ANSWERED ACTUALLY ANSWERED. IN MY OPINION, AS SAID ON THIS SITE, MANY MANY PEOPLE HERE WOULD HAVE MADE A BETTER FREAKING STORY LINE/ PLOT BETTER THAN THESE LOUSY WRITERS. FORGIVE ME FOR MY OPINION

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

the episode is FAKE and this site is COMPROMISED both by trolls and admins.

1-  FAKE  - Refer my earlier theories

2-  COMPROMISED -  Any comment you make against the episode inside is deleted after some time. Also, (this is a weak argument for obvious reasons) all the fake theories get "dislikes" and all real episode get "likes"..

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

THE LEAKED EPISODE IS THE REAL DEAL

However, it is a unfinished copy, meaning that there will still be some post production improvements. Sorting out the soundtrack, making a few edits, maybe even add or remove some stuff. But overall it is the episode that will air on Sunday.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hi everyone, two things, number one, http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=EsnqP1PummY&desktop_uri=%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DEsnqP1PummY
Be warned, it contains spoilers.

Number two, where can I watch the "rough cut" of episode 8? It seems everyone has watched it but me and I can't find it anywhere..... Thanks everyone.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

oh HELLER is just messing with us as I said in my theory #13688. He just wants to satisfy the junkies on this site and the only way is to lower the expectations by red-herring this fake thing.

Dont you see it? "The game's over and I won" said by the sherriff..

1-  He suddenly speaks in a different voice. 50% hoax identified. Ok u wud say, he just wanted to create that impression of the phone RJ effect to Patrick and all and so the sherriff is made to move is shoulder and all. but its a lame effort really coz.....

2- In the promos shown officially, when RJ utters that line, the official footage has is lower body shown. U mean to say that there will be a scene in the official promo and wont be in the main.

then Heller is not just dumb, he is also unprofessional and in his own world. But no, they compromised RJ's facial expressions while uttering such a important line coz they cant show it in promos but that line is important and needs to be uttered and RJ can only show his back in that promo-scene. so if the sanctity of promo-scene's law is to hold, this episode has to be a fake.

also, the 911 and other small things are just a spoof.
and Patrick dint tell/ask the mind trick coz thtats real and to be revealed on sunday. the bomb thing is either bullshit or small..

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Guys, you all think by your hearts not by your mind. you just want from the leak ver to be unreal but thats not going to happen. if the leak ver is not real then why they record it and why the actors act their roles in it? exept that mater and move on.. thats was the worst episode in the history of the series!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on