Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Thomas McAllister

Thomas McAllister
Suspected in 1k+ theories

THE THEORIES

Everybody can write better sricpt than this piece of shit! Fuck Bruno Heller and fuck all The Mentalist episode writers! We are so disappointed! We have been waited for more than 5 years the big reveal, and it was zero! Nothing! There are still hundreds unanswered questions! We had been fooled by son of a bitch Bruno Heller and his team!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

SPOILER ALERT

Ok, for those of you who already watched the LEAKED episode, I am pretty certain it's not a fake, but if it was, it'd be such an amazing thing, hahaha.

I know that those who did watch the episode, it was disappointing but bear with me, that's the reason the show didn't end or won't end this Sunday, I believe the coming episodes will clarify all the mysteries, all the questions and somehow bring the show's reputation back.

I really hope so.

And yes, I believe Red John is Thomas McAllister. Hahhaha

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

......

No.

Just NO.

Let's break into heller's house and draw the smiley in pigs blood on one of his walls.

THIS HAS BEEN SUCH A CON. SO MUCH ANTICIPATION! SO MUCH EFFING MELODRAMA ON INTERVIEWS AND THIS... THEY HAND US THIS PIECE OF FLAMING SHIT FROM REDJOHNS PINKO PIGEON FEARING ASS?! 

I MEAN SERIOUSLY? WAS BRUNO DILDOFUCKING SIMON BAKER'S ASS USING A DOUCHE AND THEN LIGHTING THAT UP BEFORE WRITING THIS EPISODE?

It can't be real can it? It JUST can't. This is such a cop out. Such a betrayal. 

Who cares if it was McAllister, atleast SELL it. LITERALLY NOTHING WAS ANSWERED.

I GET THE 911 call and pleading for his life bit but seriously! After all the pain and suffering and pondering and theorizing, atleast if you want to show RJ as human, there are better ways than that crap.. 

I've watched it like 6 times now. It just does't make any sense.. Has Bruno been faking it all along.. ?

Seriously bruno, if this is the real episode. Delay. Delay the show for 2 months for all I care. But please re-shoot and re-think the direction. You've literally killed off the show. There's no way it comes back from this... there won't be a new season. And I'm pretty sure this season won't cross the 15th or 16th episode either. Sure we'll tune back in for the next 2-5 episodes at most. Hoping for some retribution.

There won't be any retribution. PIGS BLOOD SMILEY ON BRUNO'S HOME. END OF STORY. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Woke up at 6 AM this morning, didn't eat, didn't drink, didn't SHIT, didn't shower, went to my laptop to check on the eventual spoilers for the upcoming episode, then holy shit links of the actual episode everywhere. Excited as fuck.

Then....after 3 hours of watching and re-watching hoping that it is a silly PRANK. TURNS OUT THIS PIECE OF SHIT(NOT WRITING BTW) IS FUCKING REAL. WHAT A FUKING FIASCO. Waste of energy and time. I think I puked a little bit inside my mouth.

THIS CAN'T BE HAPPENING. I CAN BRING A FUCKING 5 YEAR OLD TO WRITE AND ENDING MORE COMPELLING. HELL EVEN MOTHERFREAKING ZOMBIE PARTRIDGE OR CHUBBY SMITH COULD BE MINDBLOWING.
 
WHAT THE ACTUAL FUCK HELLER? MIGHT WANNA PASS THAT SHIT YOU'VE BEEN SMOKING 'CAUSE I DESPERATELY NEED IT.

BERTRAM FALLING LIKE A DOMINO, THE FUCKING PIGEON, AND TO TOP IT OFF THE FUCKING 911 CALL WAS THE KILLER.

WHAT THE FUCK CBS?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

PIGEON PAWAAAAAA!
Johnny Johnny, dont'you cry,
you have given your best try,
what a great and clever killer
could be screwed by fucking pigeon

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

First off i did watch the episode yes it was horrible and really bad scripted. My guess that episode is a alternate ending for the dvd box. Yes cbs has screwed up in the past it was not hacking it was a embedded source code 1. Cbs is not that dumb. 2. They have a system that alerts them if a high amount of downloaded/uploaded data is being used. I think the episode is real but 50/50. No i am not one of those people that are denying it because of how horrible the episode was its just certain things happened and were said that is not typical heller. We will see sunday another ending. Its just my feeling and theory

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Having watched the leaked episode, which I'm certain is more or less the
episode that will air on Sunday. The word that keeps coming back to me
is laziness.

Laziness on the part of BH, the writing staff, and
everyone involved with making what should have been a fantastic finale
into not just a disappointment, but an insult to all the fans who have followed and made the show from day 1.

They
could have made McAllister a great Red John. They could have taken the
time to dedicate the entire episode to the reason why everyone has tuned
in for six years.

Yet what I can only describe as sheer laziness and expedience turned a potentially legendary ending to the story into a forgetful one.

All the avenues that should have been explored were ignored:

A clever explanation on RJ knowing the 7 suspects-just looked over.

He Is Ma-not a mention of it.

How Red John recruits his followers, and why are they so willing to give complete devotion to him, to the point of suicide.

A
history to himself as a serial killer, how he began as a killer to in
his own words-"building a secret empire controlling thousands of lives."

How he is able to put people like Kristina Frye, Rosalind and others into that trance like state.

No explanation of how Bret Stiles knew the location of Kristina Frye, and what RJ was planning back in S3.

Not a mention of Bradley Whitford's RJ at all.

Not
even a talk of Luther Wainwright found dead in the back of the limo in
S4, Lorelai Martins, or The Red Barn where RJ presumably made his first kill.

The
whole episode just reeked of laziness, and was a squandered opportunity
to give the RJ story a fitting ending. Not only do they breeze over the
past history of the show, and not give any good explanations, the
episode itself lacked any kind of excitement or structure. The time
spent on the whole FBI angle was unnecessary, when it could have been
put to a proper showdown between Jane and RJ.

The best they had was that Jane had a pidgeon underneath his jacket!?!

The RJ we knew would never had admitted to being sorry for murder and being afraid of death, knowing he was dying.

I would also have liked RJ to have kept his high-pitched voice throughout and reveal that his deeper accent was just a front.

Also just like Timothy Carter, there was no real proof that McAllister really was RJ.

They didn't have to close all the loose endings, but to simply ignore them ALL, just showcased laziness on the part of their team. A waste.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on