Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Reede Smith

Reede Smith
Suspected in 124 theories

THE THEORIES

No it's not Reede Smith because Red John is possibly his partner Gabe Mancini 
The clues are 
HE IS MAN=He is Mancini
666=He is called Gabe Mancini for a reason just like Red John and Carmen Lee it links to the 666. Bruno Heller wrote him in so he knows his name links to 666 so why have that name which not many people notice and not have him appear so far.
Bertram also=666 but he is at the top of most peoples list and when you look at the 666 theory not many people will notice Gabe Mancini just Gale Bertram. So why would Robin Tunney be shocked that its Bertram but she would  be shocked if it was the guy she did one or two scenes with in season 5.
He fits all the descriptions and he is the right age.
If he is RJ it explains why Red John never killed Lisbon.
After reading all the theories about 666 it just has to be someone who links to it.




Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Anagram?

Reede Smith - The red is me?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

disrespecting us and type redjohn in front of our eyes bruno bitch
I SAW WHAT U DID THERE
http://i43.tinypic.com/35nc9ir.png
14 =R
3=E
7=D
This is reede smith car while jane was texting him in last episode

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I'm fine with ANYONE else than Reede Smith. 

Reasons why Smith would make the worst RJ out of all suspects:

1. Too chubby

2. Appeared in 1 episode (before season 6) with no important, memorable appearance. Just a side character, the real FBI agent in the episode was his partner.

3. First appearance in season 5. This alone would make the reveal terrible.

4. Had barely even talked to Jane

5. He's already revealed to be bad and was shown killing Kirkland.

6. If he was RJ then no appearance before was RJ... I want The John from s2 finale to be the real one.
  
There are more reasons too. Hit the green button if you think Reede Smith is the worst suspect of em all. Hit the red button if he'd be a good RJ. 

I want to know what others think.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

the three dots the girl from the last episodes showed to Jane were vertical, the three dots on the three suspects are horizontal ..is it a clue,,or because she was dying she don't know what to say
 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

FIRST OF ALL Red John is not 1 person BUT 3!!!! (dont read v4 watching S06EP06)
the girl who died in the S06EP05 said he has 3 dots on the left shoulder.
My theory is the three dots resemble the three people.
Those are:
1,Reede Smith not just he has 3 dots on the shoulder but afraid of heights and also the Tiger Tiger Motto thing that he said to the truck driver that was transporting bob kirkland when he shot him
2.Thomas McAllister not a lot of proof since he is NOT afraid of heights but he has the 3 dots tatoo that's all i know
3.Gale Bertram other than the 3 dots the time Patrick told him about the meeting he called someone and said he had "an interresting conversation with patrick jane"
and there's a high chance Patrick shot at least 1 of them cuz we heard gunshots B4 Lisbon arrives and the explosion
ofcourse jane could've told them to move then blew the place up but.
so that's my theory tell me what you think about it and if you agree or not

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I am trying to think outside the box here people, so listen me out.

I hate reading those theories about "I actually think RJ isn't a person, but a number of people, blah blah."

But I had a breakthrough that explains almost everything: Reede Smith AND Brett Partridge are/were Red John!

Before you dismiss this, think about it! Who is the least suspected of the 7 suspect on the list? It's Smith. And who is the most suspected? Mr. Partridge!

Let me explain... I think, Smith and Partridge were working together as Red John. Smith was killing people (so he is the real Red John we're looking for) and Partridge was doing all the other things (calling Patrick, breaking in the CBI computer, visiting Sophie Miller). They kinda needed each other, because they complement each other perfectly!

A lot of us has been asking ourselves: "How did Red John suddendly become so sloppy?" I have also seen a lot of theories "RJ wouldn't hire an amater to bug the office."

Think about it. Before, there were two. Partridge was doing all the little things, but Patrick started suspecting him a little more. Maybe Smith got scared Partridge would say too much if Jane gets him alone, so he killed him. Why is his death important at the start of the series, like Heller suggests? Because, RJ no longer has a partner who would do the little things for him. He now has to do both, the killing and figure out what Patrick is planning. Before, it was Partridge who gathered information about Jane and Smith knew everything before it happened. Heller said we would be dissapointed, when we figure out how RJ was always a step ahed of Jane. This is significant, because not Jane has the leverage. And I truly believe he killed that girl in last week's episode.

That' why RJ has become so sloppy recently! He doesn't have the "brains", because he killed Partridge.

Also, Smith was clearly the superior in that meeting at the start of the season, when he was almost giving orders to Bertram. He is afraid of heights, that's clear to everyone. And he has a bad temper. Jane family got killed, because Jane said something bad about RJ on TV and within seconds, RJ raged, drove himself to their house and killed his family. I think he has grown as a character now and has become more calculative and isn't letting his emotions getting the best of him.

Also, he isn't thrown at us all the time, so that means something. I just can't figure out the connection to Visualize yet. If you know something that connects Smith to the cult, comment.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on