Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Reede Smith

Reede Smith
Suspected in 124 theories

THE THEORIES

'That plump, annoying FBI agent who appeared once in season five? No way!' I hear you say.

That's what I thought too at first. Let me explain...I'll start with a quote by Bruno Heller:

"Red John is like Waldo, lurking in the background"

Now most people assumed that Reede Smith only appeared in the season five opener.

Wrong!

In episode 5x18 guess who I saw in the BACKGROUND about halfway through the episode? Reede Smith

I'll have to give it to Bruno Heller, because he placed Reede Smith in a position where he was too far away to be easily noticed, yet possible to be picked up by the subconscious mind. But I, being observant, was able to spot him.

This intrigued me to investigate further to see if this was the only episode Reede appeared in. I discovered that he also appeared in 5x06, and - briefly - in 5x16.

Virtually unnoticeable to the average watcher of the series, Reede Smith - aka Red John - is, as Heller correctly put, "like Waldo". You have to look for him to find him.

Of course, this is no conclusive proof that Reede Smith IS Red John, but it is certainly strong evidence that might suggest so.


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

  I noticed thet there is powerfull name symbolism in this tv show and in my oppinion the most powerfull name in this show is REEDE SMITH and il explain why :
PART 1
Fitst of all the names in question:
1. REEDE SMITH
- REEDE is a variation of REED [ From an English surname which comes from multiple sources, including Old English read meaning "red" (originally a nickname given to a person with red hair or a ruddy complexion)]
-SMITH [From an English surname meaning "metal worker, blacksmith", derived from Old English smitan "to smite, to hit". ]
2. ROY TAGLIAFERRO
- ROY Anglicized form of RUADH [Gaelic byname meaning "red", often a nickname for one with red hair]
-TAGLIAFERRO: Virgil Minelli first realizes "Tagliaferro" means "cut iron" or "cutting iron" ("taglio" = "cutting" and "ferro" = "iron") in Italian.
3. RED JOHN
- RED: It was originally a nickname given to a person with red hair or a ruddy complexion.
-JOHN [ English form of Iohannes, the Latin form of the Greek name Ιωαννης (Ioannes), itself derived from the Hebrew name יוֹחָנָן (Yochanan) meaning "YAHWEH is gracious".
-YAHWEH [A name of the Hebrew God, represented in Hebrew by the tetragrammaton ("four letters") יהוה (Yod Heh Vav Heh), transliterated into Roman script Y H W H. Because it was considered blasphemous to utter the name of God it was only written and never spoken. This resulted in the original pronunciation being lost. The name may have originally been derived from the old Semitic root הוה (hawah) meaning "to be" or "to become".]
-So if JOHN means "YAHWEH is gracious" and YAHWEH means "to be " ,"to become" then JOHN means : "To be gracious";"To become gracious"
Now RED JOHN is the stage name the time when he shines , the time when he is gracious and the rest of the time he is a normal guy an ordinary joe .

PART 2

Besides of the name there is the issue of the William Blake poems wich kind of fits REEDE SMITH :
-To understand "The Tyger" fully, you need to know Blake's symbols. One of the central themes in his major works is that of the Creator as a blacksmith. This is both God the Creator (personified in Blake's myth as Los*) and Blake himself (again with Los as his alter-ego.) Blake identified God's creative process with the work of an artist. And it is art that brings creation to its fulfillment -- by showing the world as it is, by sharpening perception, by giving form to ideas.

*Los, Blake's spirit of poetry, vision, and liberation, is a blacksmith.

William Blake structured his poem with six Quatrains, or four line stanzas. In these stanzas, he uses a variety of rhyming couplets, repition, powerful imagery and alot of rhetorical questions to enhance the piece.He begins the first quatrain with “Tyger! Tyger!burning bright.” Right away he uses repition to catch the reader’s eye. The word “Tyger” is a symbol of all creation. In his poem, “The Lamb”, he uses the Lamb as a symbol of innocent mankind, where as the “Tyger” is a much more wild, mysterious and ferocious animal capable of great good and terrifying evil. Blake then supports that idea by describing the Tyger as “Burning Bright” The burning bright meaning being so ferocious, being so capable, so intelligent, and having the power to do anything. Going along with the idea of the Tyger being a wild, mysterious creature, he uses powerful imagery with the line “In the forests of the night.” This imagery creats an awesome scene of a dark, mysterious environment in which the Tyger is lurking. This suggests that the Tyger is like a creature of the night, very dark, very mysterious, and again, capable of doing unknown goods and evils. Blake ends his first quatrain with a rhetorical question. “what immortal hand or eye could frame thy fearful symmetry?” The immortal hand or eye Blake uses is referring to a God. So he is saying, what God could create or “frame” somethin g that is both beautiful, symmetrical, and also so terrifying and fearful. The God who created such a creature is fearful because he made this beautiul creature of mankind to have free will. With free will means that they can choose to do right and wrong, and that in intself is terrifying.

So as you can see in the end there is a powerfull symbolism in the REEDE SMITH first of all from the names REEDE SMITH -> ROY TAGLIAFERRO -> RED JOHN
And then secondly William Blakes poem "The Tyger" has a powerfull symbolism in wich the God Creator is a Blacksmith from here the resamblance with the names SMITH and TAGLIAFERRO

PART 3

We've seen on other occasions along the show that RED JOHN used anagrams so its nothing new to him to do it again .
REEDE SMITH is the anagram for THE RED IS ME yet another reason to belive that he is RED JOHN

As PATRICK JANE said countless times along the show :

"THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS COINCIDENCE"

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

 * Kirkland is not for sure RJ...more like a RJ follower.....Lorelei told PJ that he and RJ shook hands but they never became friends....Kirkland and PJ didnt even had the time do became "friends" because he had shaken his hand one episode before Lorelei said that, and one more thing is lorelei couldnt know if Pj and Kirkland did even shake their hands

*Bret Stiles....too old, but knows who RJ is...

*Gale Bertram...could be, but something tells me he is going to get killed in season 6...so maybe he is not the one...

*Sheriff Thomas McAllister..Jane tricked him in Rock, Paper and Scissors game...somewhere i read he will be back in season 6 second episode Red-Winged Blackbird...he could be RJ for me.. 

*Brett P....when Pj and BP first met, PJ didnt gave him some big attention...he says he is a ghoul enyoying his work too much...and that he someword him...something like irritates him...also Brett told that he sees the smiley in blood for the first time for real...or something like that...he is too young to be RJ and i think he is maybe his follower.

*Ray Haffner....well maybe he is RJ, to shock us all at the end...and he and PJ were never friends, the age fits...

*Reede Smith... is a guest character appearing only in the Season Five premiere so far. Also it's been noticed that his name could be derived from 'Reed' which also means 'Red'. It has also been found that Reede Smith is an anagram for: "the red is me" and "theme is red", which would be fitting were Reede Smith to be revealed as the infamous Red John...also he and PJ were never friends...he most common translation of Tagliaferro is iron-cutter, word to word it would be cut-iron (Cutiron).But another translation of Tagliaferro is ... smith, so Roy Tagliaferro could be translated in english into Red Smith.

WHAT DO YOU THINK?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Reed can mean red, also we know that Roy means red.

Tagliaferro means iron cutter or iron worker, and smith refers to people who are blacksmiths. A blacksmith is a metalsmith who creates objects from wrought iron or steel by forging the metal by using tools to hammer, bend, and cut.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I think Reede Smith is RJ. its just a guess and it feels like he's red john and "for" a fact, overweight people have easier access to high pitch voice which we have heard RJ use. Not to point any fingers but reede smith is a little overweight. if not reede smith i could think robert kirkland is RJ:
* he knows alot about agencies because he works with homeland security
* he stole PJ hole research to catch up with his suspects to later be revealed in the season 5 finale
* his and PJ first meeting: "you don't know me, but I know you"

but I still think its Reede Smith

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Not saying he's RJ because i seriously doubt he is, but couldn't he be Red Johns contact in the FBI that is mentioned in the series 4 finale ? 

Thats why i think he's on the list. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

If Red John can truelly manipulate people, how can we be sure Rosalinds description of RJ is real?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on