Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Bret Stiles

Bret Stiles
Suspected in 550 theories

THE THEORIES

you pick your favourite RJ suspect and i will invent a different story. I bet its gonna be better story than the shit you all had to witness. So the story begins with RJ being a teenager. he had a close relationship with his father who thought him everything. One day his mother kills his father for some reason and that develops his hatred for women.His mother goes to jail and has a death penalty. RJ then becomes a member of visualize and meets stiles. Stiles tries to cure his traumas but with no success. He sees in him a dark angry man. However RJ learns many things from visualize cult and grows smarter and smarter. one day in 1988 stiles sends him on elliston farm where he gets into a fight with two other members. since he cannot control his anger he kills them both and draws a smiley face. he escapes visualize, stiles now knows his identity. Over the next 10 years RJ gains followers, money , power. He picks followers with troubled past like his and among them are michael kirkland who later dies because he wanted to betray him.Rj also creates blake association so he can escape the police . his identity is only reveald to bertram.In  1998 he starts killing again women because he hates them. he learns about jane and his happy memory from barlow family ( they are also his followers). He knows about the list of seven because he does everything jane does. Jane and him meet at the park jane kills him. Rain starts to fall and jane starts to cry but at the same time he smiles so his face looks like RJ smiley face.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

nice one heller
the leaked episode is fake .. RJ is not mcallister
the real RJ is him :
http://im35.gulfup.com/nH9Sf.png

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Apparently there was a faked leaked episode???? Can someone please tell me who red john was in this or provide a link for it?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I expected PJ to sing something in the church

I got only a fucking pigeon in my pocket
This is fucking awesome




The hell did I just watch

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

-Red John dont have a tatoo

-Red John explode Jane's House and fake his death

-why jane say to the police to search for bertram if he want to kill him?, because Bertram is not RJ, jane is distracting the police

so possible candidates, Stiles and Haffner 

Stiles is more likely

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

This leaked episode was a huge joke. Worse than dexter finale (even if I liked it).
It is clear that it was a trick played on us, to mock our silly theories.
Because of this :
- no explanation about the list (which could have a bad influence on the real one)
- pidgeons everywhere (to mock our paranoia, red john is not afraid of it of course)
- the woman with knife (funny scene)
- the actor who plays Young Man ( The only thing I agree with)
- Partridge's death unexplained ( I think he helped PJ more than we think.)
- PJ saying "Fake your death easily" (to mock our tendences'n'abilities to not trust any death)
- RJ saying "one step ahead" (same thing)
- The fbi agent who is a better reader than Red John.
- fbi agents following wrong car (same tip used in sixth episode)
- Red John dialing 911 (funny scene, not only sociopath but also a pussy)
- some scenes seemed to be uncomplete and badly patchworked.

I am so tired I forgot 75% of other things.
Well I hope I'm right else I will think red john used mc allister as timothy but it worked this time.
See you Monday.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Ok so for those of you that have seen it in using myself, quick poll;

If it is the real deal, which it very well may or may not be,

Were you massively disappointed and won't carry on watching the show

Or liked it and will carry on

Green for screw that what a terrible climax
Or red for I liked and will carry on

Personally I disliked it, and not because of who was red John, but how horribly done the whole thing was.
Just my opinion.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on