Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Bret Stiles

Bret Stiles
Suspected in 550 theories

THE THEORIES

Just a reminder - Sherriff was not the red john . Its the 2 years in between when/where the magic happens - looking forward to find out that Roger at the beach is - Stiles - is RJ.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I wish there was somebody who worked in the production of the mentalist to confirm for us if RJ is really dead,so we can all stop wasting our time watching this new garbage theme.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I'm french, so sorry for my bad english. But watch you season 6 part 8 time 36 min and surprise a ghost!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I've questioned Stiles as being RJ for a while [I mean come on, this is friggin' Malcolm McDowell we're talking about!! A FAMED actor spanning DECADES who TURNED DOWN KNIGHTHOOD from the Queen of England! Plus, the guy killed Captain Kirk, for cripe's sake! He's not taking a small role in The Mentalist]

BUT -- because he's always been such a famed villain, I thought, it's almost too stereotype to make McDowell your villain now. YET, he's clearly VERY IMPORTANT in this story -- and definitely very much ALIVE.

My theory on Bret Stiles is he's family to Red John...

RJ is Stiles illegitimate child.  How else do you get Daddy to pay attention to you?


Something about this makes me think of Queen Elizabeth I: the REDHEADED illegitimate daughter of Henry VIII -- after all, Heller is from England, [as are the real Stiles & Rigsby, Simon Baker from Australia] and in America, famous celebrities, even crazy cult leaders, are the kings and queens [and their children are usually really f@$cked up.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

WHOEVER RED JOHN IS   THEY WILL HAVE TO SHOW THAT PERSON DOING A RED JOHN MURDER AND PAINTING A RJ SMILEY FACE      either in present day to a major character    or in flashback killing Jane's family    

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Guys, Hi.

The Mentalist show have had dramatic twist towards carelessness towards its viewers.

We watched this show for years, we loved it, we expected super mental level from Bruno Heller, but he showed himself as incompetent.
He couldn't link the clues he made himself, he ignored Rosalinda's description, Fyres.
The so called Psychic Sean Barlow said that Red John has real powers...We heard that a lot.

Guys, people devote their life, sacrifice themselves ect only for spiritual reasons.


This only Bret Stiles has. He draw a face with blood in the Ceremony...

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

McAllister was just another Timothy Carter.  Stiles and Haffner are still alive.   either Stiles is Red John and Haffner is his right hand or Haffner is Red John and Stiles is his mentor      does anyone really believe McAllister survived the blast and Stiles and Haffner (who are way more interesting characters) just died without a second mention      no fuckin way       the big twist will be Stiles and Haffner are still alive     it's also possible in the world of the Mentalist that Partridge or a Kirkland Twin are still in the race for whoisredjohn?  just sayin it's possible     what's not possible is Bruno Heller getting all pissed at CBS and deciding to sabotage the entire show and then moving on to his new tv show. . . . a show set in Gotham but without Batman....ya can't wait       since the season isn't over I have to operate under the assumption that McAllister isn't Red John(just like Carter)  and that this is a season long con by Heller &Co. to give us the rightfull RJ end story that everbody wants    the show is Red John without him there is no show        and when they do reveal the real RJ we will see him kill and we the audience will be shown all the answers in flashbacks    key moments in the RJ story    like actually seeing the death of Jane's family with Stiles or Haffner doing the killing   or a scene that shows what he did to Christine Frye   show me in flashback Red John painting a smiley face and   you can't just tell us who Red John is you have to show us who RJ is       you just can't have some retard sheriff from one random episode just show up do a bad impression of the voice and claim to be a real psychic     Jane has always been one step ahead of the audience                  

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on