Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Bret Stiles

Bret Stiles
Suspected in 550 theories

THE THEORIES

Question: Why Red John recites the poem 'tiger tiger' Jane in Season Finale of season 2? What was he trying it? Reciting a poem with poetic existential background and risk of its arch enemy expose their network of corrupt cops?

Why Tod Johnson recited the poem to Jane before dying? Surely he thought Jane was a member of the Association and Blake would tell the secrets of the organization to him? Tod Johnson was a follower of Red John, but he knew if RJ recited the poem BA key for Jane?

My theory is that Red John was never part of the Blake Association, or maybe, but he wanted to break it. As part of Visualize did too, and ended up leaving.

Leaving addition, Red John can not be MacAllister (BA Creator), but someone who wanted to get him out of the way and at the same time bring down your entire system of corruption, of course, using Patrick Jane. (And he probably knows that.)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Heller gave the grandma's masturbation material until next season starts. Is that how a brother and sister show affection? Fuck me but did they not mention before that it's a brother/sister relationship?

And that scene in the beginning with the 5 students will never hold up in court in a million years.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

It would be a great twist if Bret Stiles, Thomas McAllister and Krystina Frye were all involved in the Red John case. Bret Stiles would be the great leader behind all cases. Their beliefs justify what Red John said at the end of the fourth season, he would not be sentenced for his crimes. Due to the psychic powers of Krystina, there would be an explanation of how Red John knew the names in the Patrick Jane's list. Finally, Thomas McAllister would be Red John, the person who execute the plans. There is some evidence in the series that Bret Stiles would be involved, for example, it was him who gave the whereabouts of Krystina in third season. Moreover, Red John didn't kill Krystina. Of course these are just some thoughts and the series certainly would not take that route.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hooooooold it ! hold!

In regards my accusation - all I know for certain is that there is one who pretends to be many

I did not accuse Stoopkid directly ( for what it's worth and playin open handedly - the idea has crossed my mind too ) 

For all I know , BrimgnoreW could he the part of the persona in the end too.

I don't want ANYONE to jump to conclusions - BringmW could very well mistaken Stoopkid for Stooopkid. . etc etc .. as it's easy on this forum to pretend to be someone else, -  who's already established persona here. 

I was just wondering , why on earth someone has to prove us something that has not been rendered final. Whenever you see post saying the RJ is over - you have the clue.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I totally agree with the theory presented by  jozko_haluska, Stoopkid does have multiple accounts........... you can tell from the way Bluebird keeps complimenting him over the most idiotic things. It's just plain obvious....................... also if you take a close look at the style of writing of his accounts, you'll see similarities as to where he uses full-stops and other punctuation's. Really the last thing we need on this website is a nut case roaming around praising himself.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

This "theorist" named "Bluebird" comes on a website named "www.whoisredjohn.com" and is demanding people to stop complaining about the shows inability to explain the clues they were showing us for 6 years....................... Should the last episode of season 6 end in disappointment, i think there will be more outrage among us rather than forgetting all the unanswered stuff. Real mentalist fans should and will voice their outrage through this website until all of our doubts are answered.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

We actually had a taste before of what this show is without the Red John storyline. Remember the Tommy Volker case? It was very tiresome and boring..... not to mention in the end a little boy could have convicted him. This shows backbone is and will always be the Red John storyline. Unfortunately, we the people of this site are a minority compared to the "Jisbon" fans hence even if we boycott...... this show will still get enough viewers. To sum it all up in a sentence : Jisbon fans ruined this great show.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on