Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

So, it's over. 
Unlike many of you, I actually enjoyed the show unill the very end. I won't accuse BH of anything. I don't think anyone CAN accuse whoever. You didn't come up with the show, you all came up with, I won't deny it, brilliant theories, but that's all, theories, about the main antagonist, nothing more. I didn't get why all the blind hatered was needed, if you don't like something, just fuck it. But whatever, I won't deny that I liked the end, though it was kinda cringy, but it was enjoyable finaly seeing PJ happy, trully happy after all he has been through. One of the other things I liked was how many of you, pronounced yourselves "official haters" of the show, after 608, and despite all the hateful comments you kept watching... and no, it wasn't because there was a chance for RJ, you very well knew RJ was done. And although you may say you fking hated everything after "that pernicious 8th episode", I know a small part of you smiled while watching the last episode.
I should end with thanking all of you guys, for being a part of this, it was really amusing reading all those amazing theories, many of which would have fitted a lot better than what happened, but it was not for us to decide the fate of RJ.
Thank you. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

What a waste of time the last 2 seasons have been.  That was a fine example that writers and producers have no idea where their show is going long term or just don't stick with it. what a joke. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I agree. Never watching another Bruno Heller show (Gotham or anything else) again. Waste of time & no payoff. Go into writing soap operas.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Lamer than lame two seasons. Warner Brothers executive 'convinces' Bruno Heller what is best for the show & Heller says it was genius for him to think of revealing Red John as some small town sheriff with no similarities to Patrick & ending the Red John story arc early. It just shows that good talent still has to bow & kiss ass to jackasses who retain their position in Hollywood through seniority &/ or mental dementia due to old age.

Patrick Jane's father was Lorelei's stepfather & that is Red John / Same Actor. Stoopidkid pretends to be the originator of that theory, but it was my wife & I who knew it the night it aired & not months later after Stoopkid bugged the hell out of me to reveal it & then takes it as his own. Patrick Jane & Red John even used the same color tea cup! American men are not known for drinking tea & listening to Classical Music & Red John knows all about some memory from Patrick's childhood?

Plus doesn't it seem obvious that Red John kills Lorelei on a carnival storage lot with a spotlight he is trying to show who is the real star..... father & not son?

This show went from great to shit soap opera love pandering. Gag & vomit a little.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

HAHAHAHAHAHhahaha. WHAT A JOKE !!! I'm not even mad. Screw over a brilliant show like this ? That takes some serious work and effort. So congratulations BH you almost won "the most idiotic man in history" contest. Sadly you are so stupid, you couldn't even manage ending up first. Oh boy, but thanks for the laughs, I really laughed my ass of during finale. I've seen a lot of violence and disturbing content on both TV and Internet, but if anything of it should leave a mark on my mental health, this was it!
I sincerely hope, that some american fan will go full nuts and find your ass. I hope that one day, BH comes home and he sees a smiley face on wall. His family dead and then a gentle voice saying:" I was getting the feeling, you are forgetting about me. I needed to remind you who I am. What I am." 
If I had a genie, my only whish would be a short videorecord of his face in that moment. I would masturbate to it until I would end up in some kind of ephoric-catatonic coma. I salute to all the "fans" out here who were able to see this season for what it really was. And shame on the others icluding myself. Shame on us for letting ourselves be buttfucked by uncle Bruno. Im not watching Gotham anymore, because I won't let you fuck me twice Bruno. Never posted a theory here, althought I was visitng very frequently to substitute the thrill I wasn't getting from the show. 
So please someone near Bruno, grab your murican brainwashed mojo and DO make BH regret for screwing with RJ. Have a nice day guys.


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Well that was weird.

Everything has been weird since the reveal.
The people who work for the show spoiled every twist and turn possible.
The RJ reveal was in the promo.
Bruno Heller doing a thousand interviews that i read on some weird Christian website.
He literally told us what was going to happen and that they pulled Red John from their ass.
Seriously what creator of a show built on mystery spoils his own shit?
Red Johns done, he isn't coming back , Nobody liked the Rj story line, Jane moved on, all chance of RJ return is not happening don't worry, things are going to end happy, here is a promo of our series conclusion a week in advance in case you were wondering if the characters will survive. We wouldn't wanna build SUSPENSE OR ANYTHING!!

Even weirder that they chose to recreate the show only for one short season instead of doing the Red John stuff right.
New characters and new setting, they even added a new member to the team in the finale!!! WHO DOES THAT?
Are they selling themselves to another network?

This season reminded me of Burn Notice and definitely could be on USA.
The "MENTOR alist"? Jane training some young gumshoes?
Or maybe "Red John the college years"...so we can learn about a guy who was as powerful as the president who let it all go away because he wanted to mess with some guy who called a serial killer a monster over a decade ago.
He decided it was the right time to "confront" Jane when his gang got CAUGHT and his EMPIRE WAS CRUMBLING.
He let Jane expose the tattoo clue about his people and ruin his life's work...... All so Jane could hear tiger tiger from a few people and only then he could shoot him after Jane pretended to think Bertam was Red John?!?!?!?!

Confession: There is a part of me who was happy watching the finale.
I knew nothing was going to happen so I just enjoyed it for what it was.
Seeing CBI Ron dance and Cho give fashion advice was enough for me.
Jane being a damn good con man and reading all those people on TV.
Pulling a MCguiver with the bubble gum making it a bomb.
Seeing Abbot talk cracks me up i don't know why.
He is just too damn smooth. 
Even though Patrick Jane is a tragic character and it should of ended differently,
i was still happy to see him happy after all these years of hell.
He was a great character to watch and i will miss his antics.

Been a pleasure sharing theories with all you out there.
We had wayyyy better ideas on here than real life and thats a FACT!
To all the trolls, inside your jacket pocket is a dead mouse.
It smells like dick cheese mixed with rotten fish and it will linger inside your pocket for all eternity.
No matter how many times you wash it the smell will be there. Alive.
Use a fabric softener it doesn't matter, that dead mouse is leaving his mark. mark.

 


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

All those years passed ! Thanks for the first five seasons which were amazing ,but at the end everything was ruined in the seasons 6 and 7.


About the last episode , i thought it would be related to red john but this was not the case.
I thought that all the questions will be answered like"how did RJ got the list "...
what about the woman that left after the fight with Jane at the church,what happened to her??

At the end , it was an amazing series from the start till the season 5 . And it was good to see lisbon and jane to finally get together .

I hope there will be a movie that answers all the questions 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on